Guess the Grade for B&B #93

[Shadow]

OK, here's one I sent to CGC. Take a stab at the grade.

 

Oh, the back cover scan didn't quite get the top edge. I can assure you it's straight with no imperfections. [/img] [/img]

[johnenock]

9.4?

[nik]

9.2

[herald2galactus]

id like to agree with 9.2, but for the sake of the geussing game ill go to 9.0

[-cryptkeeper-]

9.2

[MutantKeys]

9.2

[Funone]

9.4

[Dad&Son-migration]

9.6

[Darrell F]

A nice looking 9.4

[Shadow]

OK, let me first add that I thought this book was exactly what you all said (about a 9.2) when I got a few years back at the Motor City Con. Last year, when I finally decided to submit something to CGC, this had to be one. I thought "It's in great shape and I'd love to confirm it."

 

Months later, I got it back and talk about being bummed out. [/img]

[Shadow]

I know I shouldn't let it bother me, but I felt cheated from when I bought it. I can't remember who it was anymore buecause it was probably around 1998 or so. Here I thought I had such a great copy and it comes back PLOD and a 8.0. I can't find the restoration at all.

[nik]

Holy f sh

 

[Dad&Son-migration]

I'm still picking my jaw up off the ground!! I can't believe that.

[Shadow]

My sentiments also. Oy.

[herald2galactus]

well...that was...umm....unexpected..?

[johnenock]

Can't do anything about the ct, but an 8.0? Harsh.

[Shadow]

I feel like I have to re-buy it now.

[Dad&Son-migration]

At least you have the truth.. but darn.. 8.0... that's hard to believe from the scans

[Shadow]

Hard for me also.

[RaccoonRaccoon]

WOW 8.0??? Did you get the grader's notes?