Who is comic*seller

[all4comics]

Has anyone dealt with this seller before? He's sold some pretty big books. It’s also strange how he's scan's have change and really resembles comic-keys style. Are they the same seller? No that there's no more private feedback

ebay auction link

[infinite_comics-migration]

Has anyone dealt with this seller before? He's sold some pretty big books. It’s also strange how he's scan's have change and really resembles comic-keys style. Are they the same seller? No that there's no more private feedback

ebay auction link

 

And the location listed is New York!

[MutantKeys]

[MutantKeys]

Looks like the same scanner

[Comicdey]

It's probably comickeys or some affiliate.

[Sal]

i stopped reading his auctions after this;

 

Restoration-I will never sell a unrestored book as restored

 

somebody smack him already

[the blob]

"And the location listed is New York!"

 

Yeah, what's your point? Isn't comic-keys in Oregon?

[ignimbrite]

restored or not where does he get all these books? He always seems to have hundreds of high quality (even if they are over graded) books for sale.

[OldGuy]

"And the location listed is New York!"

 

Yeah, what's your point? Isn't comic-keys in Oregon?

 

No, he's in NY, hence "the point".

[nik]

A better question would be,

 

Has anyone from the boards bought one of his Raw HG books and was satisfied

[qualitycomix]

A better question would be,

 

Has anyone from the boards bought one of his Raw HG books and was satisfied

 

This isn't gio72?

[nik]

I am pretty sure it is

[FFB]

A better question would be,

 

Has anyone from the boards bought one of his Raw HG books and was satisfied

 

This isn't gio72?

 

It sure resembles his auction format and phrasing.

 

Just FYI, I believe these sellers are Kim Reganato and Johnny Hertrich of Oceanside, NY. They have used the name "gio72" and "comic*seller24" in the past, among others. They frequently sell restored books as unrestored, or books that are horribly overgraded. I had the misfortune of dealing with them back in 2003 on an Amazing Spider-Man #6 that was horribly overgraded and advertised as a NM copy (in reality, it was maybe a VF structurally with serious interior cover tanning and cream pages). They also tried to sell an Amazing Fantasy #15 in high grade as an unrestored copy. Comic-Keys said that Johnny Hertrich had purchased that issue from him as a restored copy some months prior.

 

The bottom line is to avoid this seller.

[the blob]

what's the point? anyone selling out of new york is a con artist if they have nice stuff because someone in Queens was a scammer?

 

as a comic selling new yorker you're defaming my livelihood here man, well, at least the part of my livelihood that pays the cable/internet bill and chinese/sushi delivery 3 or 4 times a week. (although this months' sales have paid my mortgage for the next two months)

[nik]

I dont think thats what he was implying

[1koko]

Comic*seller's first feedback is from Gio72 so probably a very accurate guess.

[OldGuy]

what's the point? anyone selling out of new york is a con artist if they have nice stuff because someone in Queens was a scammer?

 

Yea, that's what I'm saying.

 

[Harvey Dude]

gio72 (private) no longer a registered user.

[the blob]

"Comic*seller's first feedback is from Gio72 so probably a very accurate guess."

 

I think this is better evidence than libeling a metropolis of 8 million+ residents (plus another million or so illegals).

 

Personally, I think New Mexicans are very shifty people.

[infinite_comics-migration]

"Comic*seller's first feedback is from Gio72 so probably a very accurate guess."

 

I think this is better evidence than libeling a metropolis of 8 million+ residents (plus another million or so illegals).

 

Personally, I think New Mexicans are very shifty people.

 

Quite the chip you've got there on your shoulder. You totally missed my "point" by jumping to conclusions with you hair-trigger temper. Relax, dude!

 

And now that it seems to be Gio72, there are 2 comic book scammers in New York! I can't believe it, no way!