Another All Star # 4 on eBay

[Antonio]

There is another copy of All star # 4 which is currently on eBay. I need a copy, but am kind of turned off with the coupon cut out. How would you grade it?

There is another copy with a mouse chew which is just a shame that happened.

 

Here is the better copy. Good- maybe?

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/All-Star-4-March-Apr...1QQcmdZViewItem

[Dark Knight]

well unless it gets a qualified label, it may boost it up to a GD or GD+ at the most. But then, I'm not too familiar on the criteria of a qualified grade. Im also not too familiar on how CGC would grade loose interior pages. I'm guessing if it gets a qualified grade, probably a GD.

[ciorac]

Looks like a nice solid copy, if it looks like it will go cheap enough I wouldn't mind that much about the coupon.

[Antonio]

Well, I was the high bidder fir $405. I think it was a good deal. The cut out coupon kind of bothers me, but as Ciorac points out it looks like a solid copy. We'll see.

[shiverbones]

seems like an incredible bargain!

[Antonio]

Thanks Shiver! To be honest, the coupon kind of bothers me, but I am an admitted nitpicker.