PGm X-Men #40

[Shadow]

Here's a book I picked up today. I have a good guess at what I consider it. It does have a 1/2" tear on the top back cover. [/img] [/img]

[Mad Dog]

 

 

 

7.5

[Mr. Zipper]

6.5... 7.0 at best with the tear and long spine bends.

[Shadow]

I was leaning towards a 7.0 but the tear on the back cover is what has me questioning whether I'm being to leniant. The LCS was having a sale so I ended up getting it for $24 so I can't gripe even if it's a 6.0.

[Shadow]

Sheesh, anyone else want to chime in? I do value the input.

[rob_allan]

I tend to think it's a 6.5. The overall apperance is nice enough it might make 7.0 depending on who grades it. I can be harsh sometimes and this might be one of those cases.

 

**Edit** I'm still looking at this. I think it's a 7.0. Maybe I'm too lenient now.