New Gods #1 (or "You don't know Jack!")

[divad]

 

 

[grandz-migration]

9.0 That is one clean back cover.

 

Nice looking book. Close to a 9.2.

[divad]

9.0 That is one clean back cover.

 

Nice looking book. Close to a 9.2.

 

Close?

 

 

[flatrock02]

I'll give it a 9.2 nice book

[grandz-migration]

I may be wrong ( wouldn't be the first time).

 

This is what I see ( I haven't seen this book

in awhile, so If I'm seeing things "hit me baby o-n-n-ne, more, time" )

 

I see two creases on the URFC (in a black circle).

Small pieces out on the bottom (green circles).

Two tears on the top edge (violet circles).

 

 

 

 

Now if that's just the art work, than I'll say 9.2.

[divad]

I may be wrong (wouldn't be the first time).

 

Nope, it wouldn't

 

[grandz-migration]

 

I take it I'm seeing things. So I change to a 9.2

[Dick Pontoon]

I was thinking 9.2. Or 9.0 if I missed something. New Gods 1 is at the top of my list for difficult books to grade.

[marvelcollector]

9.2..despite slight discoloration noticeable on BC....

[Sal]

normally, i would say 9.2, but because it's david's book, i'm going to have to go with 8.5

[Dad&Son-migration]

9.2

[joeypost]

9.2

[divad]

normally, i would say 9.2, but because it's david's book, i'm going to have to go with 8.5

 

[Mad Dog]

normally, i would say 9.2, but because it's david's book, i'm going to have to go with 8.5

 

 

yearh im joining the 9.2 club

[Sal]

normally, i would say 9.2, but because it's david's book, i'm going to have to go with 8.5

 

 

okay, okay. 9.0. it's probably got some kind of 1/4" tear on page 12 or something

 

[Owls Head]

9.2

[burntboy]

I may be wrong (wouldn't be the first time).

 

Nope, it wouldn't

 

 

whoever said this is a tough book to grade hit the nail on the head. that starry sky background could be hiding many things. i also saw what appears to be the tiny corner crease on the URC. the "tears" and the missing piece are good questions that you failed to answer head on..........

 

being a 15 cent DC, i'm going to go with 9.0............if none of those three items are really defects, then this could grade ashigh as a 9.4............i don't think the slight BC discoloration reduces the grade at all..............

[divad]

i also saw what appears to be the tiny corner crease on the URC. the "tears" and the missing piece are good questions that you failed to answer head on..........

 

The tiniest of of corner creases/bends exists at the URFC; the other alleged "defects" are a figment of the reader's imagination - it's the artwork.

 

[UKavenger]

It's one of those covers that you want to like.... but just can't, if you get my drift?

 

Because it is Divad's I will say it is a 10.5!!