SM 1: Guess the CGC grade

[october]

Unrestored, old label.

 

Two creases on upper edge back cover are production related. Small stain on center of spine that is visible on the back cover and wraps slightly onto front cover.

 

 

[nik]

7.0

[DCman]

7.5

[Dad&Son-migration]

7.0

[Point Five]

6.5

[thedude]

7.0

[Jeffro.]

I'm going for an optimistic 7.5

 

 

 

and will probably be totally wrong.

[UKavenger]

6.5..... I really like that! Thanks for putting it up! I'm just off to get rid of this green eyed monster that has appeared!!

[Sal]

fine plus-ish

[Owls Head]

yeah... 6.5

[Sid]

pull off a 7.5 dang it

[djpinkpanther67]

6.5

[alecholland]

It looks really nice like VF- range at least, but because of that stain...

 

6.0

[Aces]

7.0

[143ksk]

6.5

 

[october]

Ok...

 

7.5 - 3

 

7.0 - 4

 

6.5 - 7

 

6.0 - 1

 

 

6.5 is right. Kudos to Pointfive for being the first to guess correctly. I feel the grade was conservative given the fantastic eye appeal of the front cover, but I can't argue that it isn't a techincal 6.5.

[grandz-migration]

I'll say......It's a nice looking book.

[Genesis Comics]

7.0

 

[backtomarvel]

Uhhhh, I was going to guess 6.5 ... really. I mean it.

[Dad&Son-migration]

Tell us the *spoon* grade already!!! oops.. who would've thought that in' wouldn't get the big ol * spoon * treatment!!