Well, I agree with No. 1 at least...

[s-man]

Best Movies Comic Based

 

I didn't even know History of Violence was a GN!

[deathlok]

Wow, I would not have put them in that order. Especially the their top 2.

[The Black Hand ®]

I don't know about the order, but History of Violence and Sin City are two great films based on graphic novels.

[lizards2]

Any ranking that would put Hulk above another movie is suspect.

 

Then I see they've got Hulk rated above Mystery Men?

 

Sacrilege!!!

[Johnny G]

Thanks for the link!

 

I was actuqlly looking to expand my comic themed/related movie collection!

 

There were a few on there that I own and didn't even know were based on GN's.

 

I suggest "Comic Book Villians". If you haven't seen it... get it now! Forget Cap #25 and get this movie

 

John

[bullseye]

Other than superman returns being on the list, (and anywhere near superman 2 WTF?) it's alright. But most people I talk to agree in my thinking that DD director's cut=like 700x better than hulk.(Yes, proven scientific fact ahem) Also, I didn't like Batman Begins, just couldn't get past patrick bateman as Batman.

[jordanscott]

Hulk made the top 20?

 

silly rabbits.

 

I'd have rated History of Violence a bit higher...but..whatever.

 

still, on the whole, mostly agee with the movies if not the order.

[The Black Hand ®]

I certainly agree with you about History of Violence... I like it so much I had to buy the dvd along with Sin City. Now I must confess to liking a movie that not many people liked....Daredevil... I've never been a big fan of Ben Afleck, but he was good in that. He was also very good in Hollywoodland, the film about George Reeves.

[toro]

Batman Begins #2??? Good movie, but a little high for me. I would have had both Superman and Superman II above that, and probably the Tim Burton Batman. I didn't hate the Hulk, but I don't think it should have been in the top 20.

 

But that's just me!

[kidcolt]

I guess everyone has different taste...here is my top 5

 

1. Superman - The movie

2. Sin City

3. V for vendetta

4. Blade

5. Batman

[Jacey]

Am I the only one who prefers Superman II to the original?

 

Just glad they didn't put Men in Black on the list, I enjoyed it, but it's not that memorable.

[valiantman]

Am I the only one who prefers Superman II to the original?

 

 

(Even when I was 5 years old, I didn't want Superman to save Margot Kidder.)

[Scheradon]

That list is retarded

 

All I had to see was 300 listed at #15 and behind Road to Perdition to know it had no teeth with me.

 

How about Conan the Barbarian? Oh no, wait, they were too busy recognizing movies like Tracy.

[s-man]

Am I the only one who prefers Superman II to the original?

 

 

[ciorac]

That list is retarded

 

All I had to see was 300 listed at #15 and behind Road to Perdition to know it had no teeth with me.

 

How about Conan the Barbarian? Oh no, wait, they were too busy recognizing movies like Tracy.

[Ivanko]

Crazy.

 

Conan the Barbarian should have been #1.

[The Black Hand ®]

I liked the Conan movies too! My governor rocks!

[deathlok]

I liked the Conan movies too! My governor rocks!

Oy

[deathlok]

Batman Begins #2??? Good movie, but a little high for me. I would have had both Superman and Superman II above that, and probably the Tim Burton Batman. I didn't hate the Hulk, but I don't think it should have been in the top 20.

 

But that's just me!

 

Hear, Hear!! Batman Begins was waaaaay overrated.

[Shadow]

I liked the Conan movies too! My governor rocks!

 

Please tell me "Conan The Destroyer" isn't included in that plural "Movies"?!? The first was decent, the 2nd gave Superman 4 a run for it's cheese money.