PGM Avengers #16 (new line-up !)

[osborn_fr]

I know, the chips kill this book...

 

 

[mdandy8]

6.0 is my feeling here, the chips do kill it, along with rounded corners, spine stress lines, wear on top edge and the ding on the bottom area of the spine (most visible from the back).

 

On the positive side it appears flat, generally clean and has some strong colors. It's this eye appeal that is keeping it from slipping (IMHO) to a 5.0 curious to see what others think of this one.

[djpinkpanther67]

5.5 - 6.0 - the corner blunt hurts it worse than the chipping (is that mild foxing on the mid R edge BC?)

[nochips]

6.5 to 7.0

[divad]

Me like Avengers #16 . . .