*POLL*would you trade DD 168 CGC NM 9.4 for X-Men ANN 1&2 CGC NM- 9.2?

[supapimp]

please vote for one or the other option

 

 

 

thanks in advance,

 

pimpy

 

 

 

[mr_highgrade]

[shiverbones]

nope! Wouldn't let a better grade important 1st app. go for 2 reprint books.

[supapimp]

your comment will be DULY noted, but that's why this is a POLL.

[mr_highgrade]

nope! Wouldn't let a better grade important 1st app. go for 2 reprint books.

 

 

 

[Amazing_Bag_man]

please vote for one or the other option

 

 

 

WOULD YOU TRADE A DD 168 CGC NM 9.4 OW/W for a X-MEN ANN 1 & 2 CGC NM- 9.2 OW/W & OW

YES

NO

 

View the results for this poll

[supapimp]

CENSUS DD 168

 

X-MEN ANN 1

 

X-MEN ANN 2

 

X-Men Annuals are KING SIZE Squarebound Giants

[buena_vista]

nope! Wouldn't let a better grade important 1st app. go for 2 reprint books.

I disagree with bones. There are many copies of DD 168 out there. The book is only from 1980. The annuals go back another 10 years or so --- plus the king sized books are harder to find in high grade --- plus you're getting two of them!

 

Actually the stats speak for themselves.

 

DD 168 - total CGC'd - 578. Total in 9.2 or higher - 276

X-men annual 1 - total CGC'd 73. Total in 9.2 or higher - 35

X-men annual 2 - total CGC'd 23. Total in 9.2 or higher - 11.

 

Do the deal, man, you'll find another DD 168!!

[shiverbones]

census favors the x's, but thats because not many were sent in. Guide favors the x's, but i think time will favor the DD. Its a close call, but i still think a 1st app. over reprints. my vote is cast....

[shiverbones]

you will find another DD 168 easier, i agree with that. I just found a raw one for $30! But, the reprint thing still bugs me....

[supapimp]

i have 3 copies of DD 168

[mr_highgrade]

CENSUS DD 168

 

X-MEN ANN 1

 

X-MEN ANN 2

 

X-Men Annuals are KING SIZE Squarebound Giants

 

 

 

 

Yeah, but that DD #168 will add a bit more prestige to your registry.

[shiverbones]

well thats another story, are they all NM? if so, let one fly!

[supapimp]

im trying to trade for a DD 168 CGC NM 9.4, my copies are RAW NM 9.4, NM-9.2,& VF 8.0.

[shiverbones]

oh, i had it backwards. Why not just send the 9.4 in to get graded & keep the x's then?

[supapimp]

i just joined the collectors socieity, but i don't know if i want to waste a submission coupon on that book.

[murph0]

It makes more sense to keep the annuals IMO. Both are squarebounds, which makes them tough in HG. And the DD 168 is a modern with some pretty high census numbers, not to mention hoarding #'s. It may feature a first appearance of Electra, but once all the talk of her dies down.. she'll become another Lady Rawhide

 

Brian

[Bonds25]

In the spirit of Greggy,

[supapimp]

did you guys vote? please cast your vote!

[Hensley300]

Do you have a preference one way or the other. I hear all except x-men annual 2 were printed in high number. I bought my x-men annual 1 from MHC back in the 80'd and got cgc 9.4 ow/w from it. I hear there is an overstock of those. Of course, I also hear from dealers such as RJ that you cant give many non-key or low grade DD's away from higher numbers? Id go with which ones are your pleasure or if its investment, the x-men. They seem to always be in demand and to command a higher return per issue than DD in high grade.