PGM: Planet 39 (thanks)

[deathlok]

Okay I haven't posted here in quite a long time, so I appreciate all your comments and grades. Unlike most I don't spam this forum with PGM in order to sell my books on Ebay without learning how to grade.

 

 

[piper]

Great book!

 

4.5, because of the accumulation of many minor defects. I'm sure it's just the scan, but is there any colour touch at the top of the book?

[mdandy8]

5.0 (depends on color touch vs not)

 

Nice book, love that title

[rjpb]

5.0 (depends on color touch vs not)

 

Nice book, love that title

 

I agree on all counts.

[Calamerica]

VG.F 5.0.

 

Possible VG+ 4.5.

 

CAL

[nik]

Front presents real nice, I think it has a shot at a FN- (5.5)

[Dad&Son-migration]

I agree with Nik, 5.5 here too!!!

 

So... when are you listing it on eBay

[Point Five]

5.0 from me, borderline 5.5, mostly for the back cover dirt & wear.

 

The front looks very nice, but I had the same concern about color touch even before reading John's comment...the top black edge just looks super dark & crisp compared to the other edges. Also, just to the right of the Rangers #25 cover repro on the back, is that a tiny color loss that's been touched up as well? Let us know what you find...

[deathlok]

Thanks for the responses. I bought the book off Ebay from Ed Kalb. Link

 

He listed it as a Fine. However, after getting the book in hand, it looks a lot less than fine. The book structurally is intact, but it the cover is dull, There is bit of tanning on the top of the book.

 

There doesn't appear to be any sort of color touch on the book. At least to my eyes. There is no discernable bleed thru, nor is there any noticeable change when viewed at an angle.

 

I plan to Lily Renee sign it in SD, so I suppose I'll find out what the grade is soon enough.

[CommandD]

I'd call it a Fine -

[sterlingcomics]

I thought the front cover was at least a FN...the bc took it down to 4.5/5.0 territory. Dry cleaning the bc will help big time I think. I concur with the ulc fc...it looks suspicious.

[divad]

Front presents real nice, I think it has a shot at a FN- (5.5)

 

[divad]

Unlike most I don't spam this forum with PGM in order to sell my books on Ebay without learning how to grade.

 

Gee, what a nice guy . . . makes you feel all warm and fuzzy inside . .

[deathlok]

Unlike most I don't spam this forum with PGM in order to sell my books on Ebay without learning how to grade.

 

Gee, what a nice guy . . . makes you feel all warm and fuzzy inside . .

 

I didn't want to single you out by name, but you understood I was talking about people like you.

[divad]

Unlike most I don't spam this forum with PGM in order to sell my books on Ebay without learning how to grade.

 

Gee, what a nice guy . . . makes you feel all warm and fuzzy inside . .

 

I didn't want to single you out by name, but you understood I was talking about people like you.

 

Nobody has to single you out - you're one-of-a-kind!

 

btw, "people like you" are narrow-minded.

[deathlok]

Unlike most I don't spam this forum with PGM in order to sell my books on Ebay without learning how to grade.

 

Gee, what a nice guy . . . makes you feel all warm and fuzzy inside . .

 

I didn't want to single you out by name, but you understood I was talking about people like you.

 

Nobody has to single you out - you're one-of-a-kind!

 

btw, "people like you" are narrow-minded.

[divad]

[deathlok]

mind over matter.

[divad]

mind over matter.

I don't mind, and you don't matter.

[deathlok]

mind over matter.

I don't mind, and you don't matter.