Game: SILVER AGE SURVIVOR SERIES - Round 12

[Shadow]

Amazing Spider-Man #1 has been chosen to depart this list. So, we're down to 9 comics left. Choose the next book to leave the list.

 

Until Tuesday night around 8:30 pm...

[Shadow]

I went with TOS #39 and Iron Man. I know he's getting the big screen showcase next year, but I feel the SA Green Lantern is just a bit higher on the pecking order. I was torn between Iron Man & the JIM #83 & Thor. But I've always liked the early Thor stories better than early Iron Man ones. Plus, Thor has a better Rogues Gallery than Iron Man.

 

Oh, and this list from Overstreet is based on value. So, I don't really buy the argument "Which book you'd rather own" because I'd be torn between the AF #15 & Showcase #4.

 

It's tougher now because I truly like every character involved.

[piper]

Green Lantern must go!

[Karma23]

Hulk smashed

[Shadow]

Green Lantern votes really leaped out of the gate.

[skybolt]

Green Lantern must go!

 

Definitely Showcase #22.

[goldust40]

Great cover, great book, but GL is now the weakest link. TOS 39 is a candidate, but there aren't any GL movies in the pipeline. Yes, he did have that sci-fi aspect to his backstory, which made him considerably different to his GA predecessor, but it isn't enough.

[Aces]

GL must GO!

[silverage12c]

bye-bye GL

[Shadow]

It's looking like a yellow avalanche.

[tth2]

Amazing Spider-Man #1 has been chosen to depart this list.

 

But now my automatic choice for this entire competition has been taken from me. Who to choose, who to choose?

[tth2]

TOS 39 is a candidate, but there aren't any GL movies in the pipeline.

Let me get this straight, Andy, we're now voting based on whether some bozo in Hollywood decides to make a movie or not?

 

Call me a hidebound traditionalist if you will, but I think I will continue to vote on the basis of historical significance.

[Raphael]

i chose the first appearance of the JLA because alot of main members of the group have more significant key issues

[Pirate]

bye bye tin can

[JohnT]

Iron Man for me. Couldn't hold his own book in the early days (had to share with Cap after initially being the main feature), up and down ever since in terms of quality. A second tier Marvel character, imo.

[ernster]

See you later GL

[thirdgreenham]

Has to be that Lantern fellow.............

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

.........hasn't it?

 

Andy

[MutantKeys]

Showcase 22

[Hawkman]

iron man must go

[alwaysbronze]

aw man, spidey got ripped last round