Here we go again...another Action #1

[Shield]

Someone did some amateur repair to make this look like an original...wouldn't you agree?

 

Linkie poo

[THE_BEYONDER]

A $ 9.90 starting bid with no reserve.....

 

I didn't know that the 1st appearance of Superman was 13 3/4" by 10"

[supapimp]

that's got to be the reprint from the 70's. heavily read of course

[THE_BEYONDER]

that's got to be the reprint from the 70's. heavily read of course

 

Ya think?

[greggy]

that's got to be the reprint from the 70's. heavily read of course

 

Ya think?

I have a high grade copy!

[THE_BEYONDER]

that's got to be the reprint from the 70's. heavily read of course

 

Ya think?

I have a high grade copy!

 

Of course you do.....

[delekkerste]

What the The seller has a 100% feedback record (973 unique positives) and he's trying to pull this ? What is wrong with these people...

 

Gene

[greggy]

What the The seller has a 100% feedback record (973 unique positives) and he's trying to pull this ? What is wrong with these people...

 

Gene

Can't trust those Kiwis!

[supapimp]

well he didn't state it was the original or what year the book came from.

[THE_BEYONDER]

If someone reads the description, and still thinks it's the 1st appearance of Supes......

[jonnydouble]

The original has two rocks bouncing off the hood,...that's how you tell the difference ...see attach

 

And two white marks over the front fender.

[ArAich]

Perhaps I'll buy it and have it restored...

[greggy]

Perhaps I'll buy it and have it restored...

Can't be worse than your other recent comic related decisions!

[THE_BEYONDER]

Perhaps I'll buy it and have it restored...

 

I thought it already was.....

[greggy]

Perhaps I'll buy it and have it restored...

 

I thought it already was.....

Tape is only considered a defect as per the CGC Gods!

[ArAich]

Perhaps I'll buy it and have it restored...

Can't be worse than your other recent comic related decisions!

 

It's all your fault...

[THE_BEYONDER]

Perhaps I'll buy it and have it restored...

 

I thought it already was.....

Tape is only considered a defect as per the CGC Gods!

 

Hmmm....

 

What is it "considered" when you pull the tape off?

[Tomega]

What the The seller has a 100% feedback record (973 unique positives) and he's trying to pull this ? What is wrong with these people...

 

Gene

 

I am not sure he knows what he is selling - he does not sell comics. I sent him this email :

 

Hello -

I just wanted to let you know that the Action Comics #1 you have on eBay is a reprint. I am very familiar with comics and can unequivocally say this is the reprint issue from 1974. In the condition that it is in, it is worth less then $4. I would suggest you change or cancel your auction immediately before you jeopardize your perfect feedback.

Sincerely,

Tom Kelly

 

We will see what happens.

Tom

[THE_BEYONDER]

What is it in his auction that makes you guys think that he thinks he is selling the 1st appearance of Superman?(what a terrible sentence )

[Shield]

What is it in his auction that makes you guys think that he thinks he is selling the 1st appearance of Superman?(what a terrible sentence )

 

Hmmm, could be the title? ACTION COMIC # 1 1938 SUPERMAN

 

Now tell me, was that comic book printed in 1938? Did you note all the payment options, and $12 shipping quote? Think someone would go to that trouble for a reprint? Note that it's up over $50 now...which some schmuck is out there hoping for a score.