Game: SILVER AGE SURVIVOR SERIES - Round 14 Retro

[Scheradon]

Even though im a Marvel fan I cant vote for B & B 28 this round ...

 

JIM 83

 

Et tu, MutantKeys?

[greggy]

JIM 83

[paperheart]

JIM 83

[Norrin_Radd]

JIM 83.... Back to Assgard for Thor. <-------- Really not liking the new smilies.

[seanfingh]

 

JIM 83 for me. But i am interested in having a 6.0-8.0 copy before I expire.

[Silver]

Thor versus the book that may have inspired Stan to create the FF (BB28)? No contest...buh bye Thunder God!

 

JIM 83!

[selegue]

unofficial count at this time has a battle between JIM 83 (8 votes) and B&B 28 (10 votes)

 

Journey into Myst 83 xxxxxxxx

 

 

Plus one.

 

JPS

[gacguy]

Got Poll?

[Samurai-Bill]

HULK 1

[FlyingDonut]

Journey Into Mystery 83. I've been voting for it for a while. Lame character, and Stan spelled his name wrong in the last panel.

[G.A.tor]

Journey Into Mystery #83 - 1st Thor

bye bye now

[Lazyboy]

Definitely JiM 83 this round.

Goodbye Thor.

[comix4fun]

Journey Into Mystery 83. I've been voting for it for a while. Lame character, and Stan spelled his name wrong in the last panel.

 

 

Well it's not like Stan was the letterer

 

Although not catching that in editing is

 

C

[joe_collector]

Stan spelled his name wrong in the last panel.

 

Wasn't that Larry Lieber who did that?

[Raphael]

Journey Into Mystery #83 - 1st Thor

 

[joe_collector]

Even though im a Marvel fan I cant vote for B & B 28 this round ...

 

JIM 83

 

Et tu, MutantKeys?

 

Without some type of anonymous voting mechanism, you'll always get this type of "mob mentality", where people read the thread, figure out what comic is getting hammered and then pile on "the winning team".

 

Check out the moment Thor overtook B&B 28 - it was pile-on city.

[seanfingh]

Even though im a Marvel fan I cant vote for B & B 28 this round ...

 

JIM 83

 

Et tu, MutantKeys?

 

Without some type of anonymous voting mechanism, you'll always get this type of "mob mentality", where people read the thread, figure out what comic is getting hammered and then pile on "the winning team".

 

Check out the moment Thor overtook B&B 28 - it was pile-on city.

 

Part of the pile on mentality though, JC, is based upon the concept that one wants one's vote to count. I, for example, believe that Hulk 1 and JIM 83 are the best candidates for vote off. I think Hulk 1 is a better choice for being the first of a very short lived series. But that vote ends up being inconsequential and puts BB28, a book I think deserves serious props for top 4 candidacy, at risk. So it's not so much piling on as it is casting a vote that means something, IMO, of course.

[CAP Freak]

Larry did the writing for JIM #83

[WEBHEAD]

JIM 83

 

WEBHEAD

[JohnT]

I've got to go with X-men #1, because it was relatively weak at the time, and unrelated to the book's later revival.

 

Am I the only one who thinks Thor is a very cool character?