I love that quote.
It won't turn out to be accurate in this case, though. Harley's rise in popularity has been building for a while. She'll be a key hobby fixture for years. When you look at BA 12 print and supply numbers, and use NM 98 as a measuring stick, you realize there may even be more room to run for 9.8s.
Five years out, $1500 for a BA 12 in 9.8 may seem cheap.
Right. "This time will be different." *yawn*
-J.
No. It'll be the same.
The same as other characters who've become leading players in the hobby and seen the values of their first appearances rise. Think Wolverine circa 1980, Punisher circa 1986, Deadpool over the past few years ... and now Harley.
There's a long history of characters becoming hobby favorites to draw from.
Or....more like the same pumped up movie hype, with the same subsequent crash.
The market has changed since Wolverine and the Punisher, and this book is being relentlessly pumped (on these boards) and shilled (on ebay).
These are not the hallmarks of long term viability.
That, and the character is rapidly becoming over-exposed.
-J.
Look, I don't make it a point to play the guessing game in comics. Not with this market or economy of the world. On the long list of "need shelter, food, clothing..." comics are way down on the list.
Having said that, not sure what your beef is with Harley Jay. You act like this book isn't 22 yrs old now. This book isn't "Manifest Destiny", or "The Strain" or anything else that has hyped in the last year or several for that fact. I'm not stating the unreasonable rise in price is good for the book, but it certainly won't come "crashing down" to $200 in 9.8. EVER.
Harley is the most popular character with women, and a lot of men. She's the most popular in cosplay, and every women I know that is into comics wants one of these. The new generation would rather have this book than any Golden Age book or even SA/BA. They aren't screaming for "CATMAN" or anything else, but for Harley.
All this and the last 2 series of her books have absolutely SUCKED. Now let's imagine a world where a Frank Miller type writer actually starts writing her series, and it's GOOD. Even GREAT.
Imagine where this book would go then.
I'm not defending this high rise. But I certainly see a lot worse places for the younger peeps to park their money than in this book.