Yes, i always buy my VF copper slabbed. What a thought out and cost effective solution.
be sarcastic all you want. but it's the truth. if the OP did, he wouldn't be having this problem. we all know that grading is subjective on raw books.
These do seem to be major grading flaws, though. Not quibbles.
Still, I wonder for the OP what would make him whole? $10? A few more books? Seems like a very good deal and the 'wiggle room' should have been disclosed up front in the transaction rather than post sale.
Is it simply lack of communication or did you really want compensation? Does seem like you got an exceptionally good deal to start with.
If I were selling, I would acknowledge the oversight, but not sure I would give back money given the deal. Maybe a credit for a future purchase? Maybe ask buyer to send back books on his dime and then refund the price of those books within the deal?
Curious what others would do in the seller's position. This is helpful for me as I contemplate starting my first sales thread.