that book, I believe, was in a cgc "trimmed" holder not too long ago
Wow, that`s a pretty serious accusation Rick, since CC`s description pretty much says the book is not restored.
I think Rick is just making a speculation.
It`s a pretty serious "speculation".
would you prefer I not make mention of the possibility
No, I think more disclosure is always a good thing if it can be substantiated. Just wondering if you could provide some more detail. CC seem to be saying, and providing Borock's confirmation, that the book was never in a CGC slab because it was unslabbable because of overhang.
I have not followed up, I only lent my observation in passing... I just recall what I "thought" was this book in a trimmed holder, and visually it struck home with me, but if I had any more details, I would have already provided ... if borock and them confirmed it was not, then I am wrong, I have no problem being wrong sometimes (Thumbs u ...so due diligence was a good thing in this case (thumbs u
I think there is enough "evidence" presented to place doubt in one's mind before bidding..that's the beauty of this Board. You don't have to wade out in shark-infested waters alone...
(thumbs u