Gotham Kid

It's all good. No issue. By the way Robert, I knew very well you had purchased them as Andre came to me first. I lacked the funds at the time for a lot purchase ( he choose not to break the set up ) and he couldn't work with time payments as he had a court issue or something. He had told me shortly after that you had purchased them.

Didn't imply anything. Only stated the obvious. They were made available. I also wrote "listed" not "consigned". You read wrong. Sorry. Some were listed on Storms' site. Didn't last long.

Were they not listed on your site for purchase ? Did they not sell ? My definition of "listed" is made available for purchase online. Doesn't really matter by whom. Apparently definition differs from yours.

Of course.

Then you should share it with Supergirl1959

Nope. The only SA thread that I follow every now and then is the AF15 thread.

The CL 35 1.0 brittle just listed would be perfect for a coverless interior with better PQ

I did that about 4 months ago.

Some were listed on Storms' site. Didn't last long.

I collected high grade SA Marvels for 5 years. No fun in the ubiquitous. I'd rather an Action Comics run as a second row.

Sure Brian ! Complete history along with it.

Holy sheit. I posted my first like.

Fair enough.

Then as Roy said, you should state ALL prices and not just the outliers. I'm fine with that. Easy to keep track of prices, etc.

there is much, so much more to this hobby than simply dollars and cents

Why would this thread be any different from EVERY other thread ?

Can you list all of them and their hammer prices? We should add those data points to the discussion as well. Or does this thread boil down to this

Hi and welcome to the CGC Boards. You're better off asking that question here

I've actually had a couple of transactions with him on the boards and all went well. I just read a thread Tony PM'd me and all I can say is

That I know less of

Consignor tried selling it on the boards not too long ago Robert. https://www.cgccomics.com/boards/topic/408509-detective-comics-37-cgc-70-oww/ As it is no longer being sold here I can now comment on the book's history. This was it's last stop: http://www.comiclink.com/auctions/item.asp?id=1128265 Glad to see consignor is still being modest in his flip. That is roughly the same price SparkleCity offered it here for when they first brought it slabbed to market, the same price they sold it on ebay (as no sale here) for and the same price it sold last year on ComicLink for. All this over the last 3-4 years. Nice book but that bottom piece out will detract from a 50K sale. We'll see ...