GoldenPRGuy

11 minutes ago, misterrmystery said:

Dying to pull the trigger on this one but Uncle Sam wants his tax money.

You and me both. Always hate it when exciting books come up this time of year! Great looking copy even with the small issues highlighted.

44 minutes ago, lou_fine said:

Too lazy to check in the HA archives right now. 

Does anybody have any idea how MMM did with his Archie listings since it seems he hasn't posted on these boards in almost 2 years now?   Just wondering if all of his hard work on detailing the Archie timeline worked to his advantage in the end.   

Not real well if I recall. Not that he'd admit it. Pretty sure it was an eBay sale... and as we all know their archives are ?.

1 hour ago, jimjum12 said:

HANGMAN 7..............................................7.5........................................C........................................$ 2000

So pretty... if only I didn't have to pay taxes too! 

Every time I see a Little Archie comic now, I think about this funny article someone once sent me. Fair warning, you'll laugh your a.. off.

Cracked Article

thx Chuck

 

Love this cover...

As most long time Archie fans know, a lot of the cover jokes are redrawn for future issues. Sometimes they're almost exact in the layouts and -script and other times they're reworked a bit.

 

During some time off in December, I thought it would be fun to start matching up a lot of the repeat covers from the 50's and 60's. I started pulling the books and ended up nearly filling a short box just getting the first 20 or so. I realized it was a bigger project than I expected. Here are some of the 20 or so that I did so far:

 

 

 

 

Wow awesome project, Tom! I'm obviously aware of them but never thought about a real effort to pull them all for a side by side look. Of what you posted the earlier covers really take the cake comparatively. And this is one of my favorite drawings of Veronica...

I have two myself. One still in the bag with the comic that was packaged with it. Comic is in rough shape.

I do love me some Zip 27...

I was going to bid about 12,000 and got shut out as quickly as you did. Agree with your grade assessment, Todd... maybe a 2.0, tops. Still a decent final price.

Watching the other as well.

Interestingly no one bid anything on the rest of Jim's auctions, except the 9 which closes soon.

My top Archie books

 

 

bravo, sir! This one makes me salivate a little bit…

And yes, I know they are all for sale on eBay.

Here's one. The trivia is it's supposedly very difficult to find in high grade due to shoddy spine construction. So bad in fact that a subtle recall was issued at the bottom of the cover of Archie #56 which gave kids in the 50's a solid financial incentive to return their copies.

Well I think it's important to call out Steve's thread and its 153 pages of Archie goodness...

http://boards.collectors-society.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=317865

But I do love any Archie thread so, I'll add some stuff.

This one seems ok.

 

Sorry about the label mixup, Tony, but those are some awesome books! Congrats again. Does CGC cover shipping when that happens?

Sure. That can be arranged as soon as I put my son to bed.

Not to exclude anyone else on the boards, but I do want to take a moment to wish all my fellow Archie/MLJ collectors a very happy holiday! This has been a fun collecting year, albeit a bit more selective on my part, and I have thoroughly enjoyed sharing it with all of you, as well as seeing all of your great acquisitions.

Let's all have a prosperous 2017 and keep this thread rocking.

 

3) GA Archie is a different story ... I realize this might be a point of contention and let me remind everyone that I'm sitting on 10,000+ Archie/MLJ comics so I wish I was wrong ... I don't think the CW is going to do much for the classic Archie market. I think those who love Archie for the art, stories and nostalgia of the 40's, 50's and so on are not the people who will love Archie for the new show. They are sure as ____ not fans of the MLJ WWII/Nazi/Bondage artwork. By all accounts, Riverdale will be super modern, edgy where it counts (drugs, sex, sexuality, etc), one-tree hill meets glee/twilight/Dawson's creek/gossip girls/90210/fill in the blank. This is not the Americana that resonates with GA Archie collectors. At best we can hope that some middle-aged money manager walks by the TV as their pre-teen/teen is watching the show and feels inspired to rebuild a childhood Archie collection. Sorry for the glib outlook guys, but when we are done buying each others books a decade from now, I think it's over.

 

Andrew are you trying to pop the Archie bubble?

Maybe

No Todd, not at all. I love seeing Archie prices climb. The titles have really come into their own value-wise and it's great to see people finding more and more special attributes in various issues to help drive interest and price (much like the headlight cover conversation that just took place in this thread). I guess sometimes I just question where it is heading. I'd be curious to know, really, how many GA Archie collectors there are out there. On the entertainment front, super hero movies are reimagined and re-released all the time, each with better special effects to capture the imagination of all generations, and all based on the story lines that were there in the beginning. I just don't think the CW program is trying to align with the classic Archie. There is likely a whole generation of people who are buying the new Archie, B&V and Jughead titles religiously and are IN LOVE with them, but will never identify with a classic Archie book. I'd love to find a way to re-energize that market. Heck, I love to see some MLJ movies made. Would be great to open the younger generation to super heroes outside Marvel.

It'll go for 30-35. If I had the $ I'd buy it.

 

Are we talking about the CBCS Pep 22 with extensive resto? Is this an IGB book?

 

 

 

This is an not a IGB. old school resto because of the re gloss... very old shoool resto 1990's style.

 

 

It was probbaly a 1.5 2.0 prior. No major pieces added or grafted.

 

 

 

If it was IGB it would be a 9.6 ?

 

You can see that there is a pencil mark ok the i of comics

 

Also the spine wear is still evident and IGB wouldnt.

 

An honest old school resto job. Well done. Definetly not An IGB

 

Also this is not a common hulk 1 made into a 9.6 but the rarest top ten golden age book

of Archie that kid named chick

 

 

Only 12 unrestored cgc and 11 resto. A total of 23 books!! compared to the 66 copies of action comics 1!!!

 

 

A pep 9.0 extensive sold for 30k with a logo from a a pep 30. This is on has upgrade potential via Matt nelson at ccs most likely. So a strong 7.0. An extensive 5.5 just sold for 21 250$..

This 7.0 can be upgraded since it has dirt ,pencil mark on cover and color breaking creases.

 

 

Also the CW archie series should help give a good boost to previous sales.

 

Well the Pep #22 CBCS copy sold for $20,250. Last year this same copy sold at CC for a little more than $23k.. Just goes to show that movies, tv shows, etc have no impact on GA keys, only SA and newer IMO.

A few thoughts ...

1) this book went cheap. If I had the cash, I would have paid more in a heartbeat, but I have way too many kids. It did have upgrade potential, which is why I liked it. Sometimes it just comes down to the time of year, potential buyers' outlook, etc. Books can have an off day.

2) I disagree that movies/TV don't affect GA pricing. I have seen GA titles heat up around movie releases, even if it's dealer manipulation, it still happens.

3) GA Archie is a different story ... I realize this might be a point of contention and let me remind everyone that I'm sitting on 10,000+ Archie/MLJ comics so I wish I was wrong ... I don't think the CW is going to do much for the classic Archie market. I think those who love Archie for the art, stories and nostalgia of the 40's, 50's and so on are not the people who will love Archie for the new show. They are sure as ____ not fans of the MLJ WWII/Nazi/Bondage artwork. By all accounts, Riverdale will be super modern, edgy where it counts (drugs, sex, sexuality, etc), one-tree hill meets glee/twilight/Dawson's creek/gossip girls/90210/fill in the blank. This is not the Americana that resonates with GA Archie collectors. At best we can hope that some middle-aged money manager walks by the TV as their pre-teen/teen is watching the show and feels inspired to rebuild a childhood Archie collection. Sorry for the glib outlook guys, but when we are done buying each others books a decade from now, I think it's over.

It'll go for 30-35. If I had the $ I'd buy it.

 

Are we talking about the CBCS Pep 22 with extensive resto? Is this an IGB book?

I understand what you're getting at Tony ... just have a feeling on this one. Not sure if I want to be right or wrong.

It'll go for 30-35. If I had the $ I'd buy it.

I'd expect that to jump at the end based on the eBay sale. That price really surprised me ... in a good way.

We shall see.

Delayed post of my one NYCC acquisition...

Beautiful copies Rick ... that 12 in particular. It is a very hard copy to find in high grade.

Ha, I don't doubt it. Ironically, emailed me after our convo showing me the results of his resubmission to CGC. Said if I didn't act fast you were gonna buy em all. I told him I couldn't compete with Tony.

I saw Met had a Zip 13 they added to their for sale list. VG for $500. I called Frank to ask him to bring it to NYCC next week so I could have a look (since they had a stock photo) and he said it already sold.

Who got it?

Went to a convention in my hometown yesterday (first I have gone to in 20 years) and picked these three up.

 

Beautiful books, Rick! That colors on that pep and that Archie 53 are so rich, look like new!