eddly

Thanks! Some great books left.

6 hours ago, Jordysnordy said:

ASM 59 - Great Romita cover ad 1st MJ cover  $360.00

I bought 2 just for “fun”. First new book off the shelf I’ve bought in 28 years!

Every book I could choose from had several spine ticks. What’s up with that?

I have found 80 Canadian price variants in my dad’s comic collection . We will be putting them up for sale in the upcoming VCC this weekend. There are a few keys that we will be submitting to CGC first. I may find some more still... just a friendly heads up. 

What is a reasonable price mark up for nonkey Canadian variants based on what you guys have seen? Double guide or perhaps more?

Still waiting to see the results for the 100 #1s... 

Any new thoughts on this book? Appears to have really declined in value since tlj.

ya 

Require lists to be sent along with grades for the 10th round.

And where to make the exchange? In their shed? 

18 minutes ago, thirdgreenham said:

The stain ate through part of the back cover and soaked into half the book, IIRC. If I were to guess, I'd say it was food or sauce. 

This is the perfect example of me wanting to know how CGC would handle this kind of defect.  An otherwise 8.0-8.5 book.

Interesting book for sure. Seems like it would be quite the horror story in terms of buying it on ebay with no back cover scan provided (raw). What do you plan to do with this book now? Sell it or keep it?

Was this book part of a collection you acquired or was it purchased on its own?

Hi thirdgreenham, can you please send a quick confirmation message that you have our lists in an acceptable format?

Doesn't the winner get a job offer from CGC? Newtsamson?

On the asm 194 back cover, was that white out or something (not the bottom left mess). Maybe just something created by the slab kind of like the newton ring effect?

For the large stain... I was struggling with that as I wasn't sure if it was distributor ink?

Still went 4.5... I'll take it.

I started at a 9.8 at first glance... then when I saw the shadow I knocked it down to 9.0... I then proceeded to do a few hours of research... slowly worked myself back to a 9.6...

Is that not a shadow on the top left back corner of the tec book?

Hmm... I haven't submitted yet... by any chance are those rank increases due to people not submitting?

What stains? 

Oh my

After 9 rounds... I feel like I’ve seen these books before in another grading contest... or maybe even this grading contest... losing my mind... carry on...

Going for a home run this round... either it will work or ill strike out miserably. 

If i am massively off at least i dont have to explain myself...

went 6.5 and 3.5... oh well

grades submitted... what did I do... ...

51 minutes ago, eddly said:

So my ranking since round 2 has been 33, 32, 36, 35, 34... for round 7 will I be 31 or 37???

I'm now 31st!!!

So my ranking since round 2 has been 33, 32, 36, 35, 34... for round 7 will I be 31 or 37???