I got my first Value Tier submission back from CGC. Overall, I am very pleased. I wanted to test my grading of gold-silver Duck books against CGC and I was very pleased. I had a few nice pre-1975 Uncle Scrooges and a Thor I wanted to add to my registry set. I was pleased with the results there too. And I had a few miscellaneous pre-1974 Marvels I wanted to get slabbed for selling.
Here are the keepers:
Uncle Scrooge 79 9.6 white pages, top-census
Uncle Scrooge 100 9.4 white pages, one higher
Uncle Scrooge 103 9.6 white pages, top census
Uncle Scrooge 110 9.6 white pages, top census
Uncle Scrooge 116 9.6 white pages, top census
Thor 228 9.6 white pages, top census
Here is the results of my grading test:
Walt Disney Comics & Stories 98 CGC 6.0, my grade 5.0
Donald Duck 26 CGC 5.0, my grade 4.0
Four Color 178 CGC 4.0, my grade 4.0
Four Color 223 CGC 4.5, my grade 4.0
Four Color 282 CGC 4.5, my grade 4.5
Four Color 291 CGC 6.5, my grade 5.0
Four Color 300 CGC 8.0, my grade 7.0
Four Color 308 CGC 6.0, my grade 6.0
Four Color 318 CGC 5.5, my grade 6.0
Four Color 328 CGC 7.5, my grade 6.0
Four Color 339 CGC 7.5, my grade 7.0
Four Color 356 CGC 6.0, my grade 6.0
Four Color 379 CGC 7.0, my grade 7.0
Four Color 386 CGC 3.0, my grade 3.0 My personal "Old Number One"
I'll post the Duck books in the golden-age "Show us Your Ducks: thread and the Thor in the bronze-age "Thor Appreciation" thread.
And here are the best of the rest:
Marvel Spotlight 16 CGC 9.8 white pages
Amazing Adventures 12 9.4 white pages
Amazing Adventures 15 9.4 off-white pages
Here are the rest:
Amazing Adventures 12 CGC 9.0 white pages, I was thinking 9.2
Amazing Adventures 14 CGC 8.0, I was thinking 9.0 My only real dud
Amazing Adventures 16 CGC 9.2 white pages
Amazing Adventures 17 CGC 9.2 white pages
Uncle Scrooge 111 CGC 9.2 white pages, I was thinking 9.4
Uncle Scrooge 40 CGC 8.0 off-white pages, no note of Barks signature on first page so I will have to resub this one
Dynamo 3 CGC 8.5 OW/W pages