Hi, I am looking for opinions on what to do about this eBay transaction. Should I leave a negative or a neutral feeback?
Basically, I won 3 CGC books from the same seller. The shipping was listed as $15 in each auction. I know I should have asked beforehand about combined shipping, but I have never had a problem getting combined shipping in the past.
Once I won the auctions, I sent the seller a message requesting a combined shipping total. He sent me an invoice for $45 shipping. I messaged him back if he could please combine shipping as he could easily fit 3 slabs in a Flat Rate box for under $15.
He refused. He actually told me in a reply that he was trying to make up for the eBay fees by charging this much for shipping. I reminded him that that is actually against eBay rules and it seems unreasonable to charge $45 for something that actually would cost $15 max.
He ultimately came down to $27 shipping.
I paid the $27 because I really wanted the books.
However, I feel that $27 shipping for 3 CGC books, which he sent in one box, and I only live one state away from him, is still way too high. In my mind, $20 would be the max reasonable to charge.
I believe that he profited roughly $15 by overcharging for shipping.
What do you think? Negative or neutral? There is no way I am giving a positive.
Thanks.