I normally would not post another company's graded comic since I always buy and grade CGC only. However, I could not pass up this opportunity to buy a "10" from PGX for the price offered - whom I've never graded or bought a comic from before. Based on the conversations here, I thought it would be okay to post this pic.
I received this today and after careful and thoughtful consideration after thoroughly inspecting this comic, I think CGC would grade this a 9.8 - maybe 9.9 at best though realistically, based on having more than 500 comics graded through CGC in the last two years (with one graded a 10 and three graded a 9.9), I believe this is a realistic assertation or "guesstimate".
The question is, do I sell this at some point for a lower premium as designated with the PGX grade, or risk a most likely 9.8 worst case scenario through CGC? I'm fairly confident based upon my experience that 9.8 is the grade at best if resubmitted through CGC. Though we all know the outlier consideration for a more "objective" grader exists sometimes...
No doubt that a CGC 10 designation would be monumentally huge for this particular comic, so worth a discussion to some degree IMO. Thanks for your insight in advance my friends!
@Funnybooks @Galen130 @onlyweaknesskryptonite @Pitboss @CGC Mike
...and a number of others here with vast grading experiences.