• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Gnasher

Member
  • Posts

    3,031
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Gnasher

  1. Apart from the spine wear, the two deep scratches above Spidey's boot hold it at a 6.5 for me.
  2. The reading edge is telling me 3.5, but the rest of the book is calling out 4.0/4.5 with the GA curve. Great cover!
  3. Pressing would help, I can't help on whether a signature would be of benefit to it. It's got potential.
  4. Spine, bottom edge and some colour loss lets it down. 4.5, with a squeeze to 5.0. Still looks a solid copy.
  5. Considering that is completely loose, it's in really good nick! Excellent!
  6. 6.0 for me owing to top edge FC, the foxing on the top margin BC, corner bend BRBC.
  7. Neal Adams' classic cover. This I think is Supergirl's 2nd appearance on a WF cover??? This one just makes me laugh....
  8. Couple more for the collection.
  9. Just found this which references the chip as a production flaw....
  10. Is that a long tear on the back cover?
  11. I took that for a deep scratch from N.A.C.'s description, and he does say that the spine is better than it looks.
  12. Debated long and hard about the spine but I'm convinced at 3.5, (just).
  13. Law of averages has to have me in the right area at least once. It's the main reason I'm on the boards, to brush up on the grading.