-
When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
-
Posts
3,559 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Forums
CGC Journals
Gallery
Events
Store
Everything posted by silverage12c
-
No real flaws that aren't visible in these pics. Staples are secure, centerfold and all wraps attached nicely. Obvious cover creases and spine stresses, and a 1/2" tear near the cca stamp upper-right front cover. I always tell myself I'm going to sell some of these keys as I find them, and then I get all attached. This one's probably a keeper now. Thanks for looking
-
PGM X-Men #1 Second Copy
silverage12c replied to SOLAR BOY's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
I'm jumping on the 1.5 train -
Nice book! And damn these squarebounds with the spine issues. I would be taking a soft white eraser to those white cover areas to clean up some of the dirt, for sure I think the spine split is much less than 1", I think I have this at a 5.5 with a shot at 6.0
-
PGM Silver Surfer 4
silverage12c replied to Shabby Road's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
Looking 4.0ish to me, I would say? A number of defects here that can't be helped by a C&P, but I hope you'll share pics after that's done -
PGM Moon Knight 25 White Dot Variant?
silverage12c replied to comicginger1789's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
I think the bottom corner (spine side) is blunted and abraded, and will keep this capped at no better than a 9.4 after press. This is most visible looking at the back bottom-right corner. I may be wrong, but I don't see it reaching 9.6 due that corner blunting. If you press, be careful of the slight front cover overhang -
7.0 with potential to reach 8.5 after C&P
-
PGM Amazing Spider-Man 129
silverage12c replied to oatcrunch's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
I'm on board with this, at a 7.5 ... nice book -
PGM Fantastic Four Annual 6
silverage12c replied to silversurfer275's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
2.0, and holding my breath the cover doesn't fall off ;) -
Please Grade My Sub-Mariner #1 1968
silverage12c replied to Adrift's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
Wish my copy were in this condition. (It's a beater/reader). I think the small piece out, and the tear at bottom staple, will cap this at a 6.0, even after a press. Just my 2 cents -
Nice book Those 2 top corners are the only real issues I see. I'm gonna say 7.5, with that small piece out upper-right back cover and the corner blunting.
-
GRADE is IN --- Please Grade my ASM 101
silverage12c replied to silverage12c's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
Actually, these pics are after my own gentle press. I opted not to do more than a simple full-cover (front and back) press job on it. I didn't think that attacking the spine with a tack iron, or anything like that, was going to be worth the risk. Most of the cover damage is just an accumulation of color-breaking stress lines that are not going to be improved anyway. I also did my own gentle dry-clean work on the white areas front and back, to eliminate most of the usual dirt and light scuff marks, etc. I'm sure a pro could accomplish more than my DIY amateur efforts, LOL. But, I think this book has a grade cap due to the color breaks, no matter who works on it? -
8.0, as others have opined
-
PGM X-Men 2 *GRADE IS IN*
silverage12c replied to Jarodm5's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
Press & Clean was really effective --- very nice! -
PGM Iron Man 270
silverage12c replied to SellinMyCollection's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
Lots of spine ticks here. Even though they are tiny, they accumulate to knock this down to a 6.5 IMO -
PGM Batman #155 Low Grade
silverage12c replied to Ron C.'s topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
2.0, I think. These grading posts are fun. But, when the OP posts very good, close-up pics like these, I think the high-quality images tend to exaggerate the flaws. We're seeing zoomed-in paper fibers and every little defect even better than we might with the book in hand. Leads a lot of us to undergrade, maybe. -
GRADE is IN --- Please Grade my ASM 101
silverage12c replied to silverage12c's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
I think it must just be the lighting, because I'm not seeing it? FYI, those aren't buildings, it's an interior scene and the bottom right shows brown wooden stairs I think you, and most others here, are viewing this book about the same as I am, in the 5.0 to 6.0 range. As mentioned, it's en route to Sarasota for walkthrough service, so I'll have it back soon enough. I'm pulling for a 6.0 Universal OW, but not banking on it, LOL. -
GRADE is IN --- Please Grade my ASM 101
silverage12c replied to silverage12c's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
Thanks all for your feedback, very much appreciated! I went ahead and sent it in today for Walk Through grading, so I should have it back in a couple weeks. Will come back and share the grade when I know it. Cheers, and happy hunting for your grails, series, and readers alike -
pgm venom lethal protector 1
silverage12c replied to Sislovesme's topic in Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
That bit of spine damage in the first pic looks like the only real problem. But, I think that knocks it down to about a 7.5. (Larger pics, taken with the comic out of the bag, would be better). -
Nice gloss, lies flat. Obvious issues are the 10 to 12 spine stresses (especially at bottom staple). Tiny diagonal crease lower-right front cover, and a 3/4" printer's crease near the upper-right front cover. Centerfold and all wraps tight and attached. What do you all think? And, thanks very much for taking a look
-
Revat's Last Bronze Sale! CLOSED! GO WASH YOUR HANDS!!
silverage12c replied to revat's topic in Golden/Silver/Bronze Age Only
Green Lantern 63 CGC 8.0 $88 -
Ghost Rider 30 - 7.0 OW $4Ghost Rider 19 - 7.0 OW $6Peter Parker Annual 1 - 8.5 OW $5Iron Man 178 - 8.0 OW $2Iron Man 87 - 8.0 OW $7Luke Cage 7 - 7.0 OW $2Luke Cage 10 - 4.0 OW $1Daredevil 119 - 8.0 Avengers 168 - 8.5 OW $9Avengers 155 - 6.5 OW $6Avengers 116 - 6.5 OW $9GS Man Thing 1 - 5.0 OW She Hulk 11 - 8.5 OW $3Dr Strange 17 - 7.0 OW $3Strange Tales 140 - 4.0 OW $8Hulk 204 - 8.5 OW $3Thor 255 - 7.0 OW $3Thor 194 - 7.0 OW $6