1Cool

I'm pretty straight forward on how I do things and I would never think to offer someone some cash for a book included in an offer. I'm hoping who ever did it was trying to look out for the guy and didn't want to have him offer too much. I have no clue how much those books are worth since I stay pretty much away from coverless books in general.

thanks someone just made me an offer so I took it off and updated the offer (thumbs u you'll fit right in (are you related to chip by chance ? ) I don't think they are related - who do you think offered him money for the Action book? You??? I was worried that emoticon was confusing. It wasn't me - I was joking and was pointing the finger at Chip. Its only fair I got a finger pointed at me in the process.

thanks someone just made me an offer so I took it off and updated the offer (thumbs u you'll fit right in (are you related to chip by chance ? ) I don't think they are related - who do you think offered him money for the Action book?

Let's just move on to the next offer. Everybody smile today.

I hope you did not take my initial comment to mean your offer was a bad one. I did offer the suggestion that you may want to post up a secondary offer just because the number of people looking for a partial Batman is very small. I didn't know your situation so that's why I said it was up to you.

No strike has been given out yet. People seem to be pissed since you said you plan on selling all your remaining books which implies you are planning on selling the Walking Dead slab once you get it. Didn't you have the partial Batman book up in your offer up for sale recently? I'm trying hard to not read into your statement about selling all your other books so could you explain it more. Was the partial Batman 4 a keeper book you were planning on saving unlike all the rest of your books? I type way to slow since Harvey already posted pretty much what I just said

so who took my comic? I think the answer would be no one so far. Any other options you want to test the waters with (up to you).

1st page always list who took which offer.

Wild guess but I think he wants it.

Nope the offer isnt rescinded or nope you wont let it slide It's not rescinded or I would have updated the first post. So I am confused, are Mystery Boxes okay now? I'm sure a true mystery box would be against the rules but giving someone $150 to spend in your sales thread is ok. Its definitely one of those grey areas but since ComicalGems has listed the keys in the boxes they are not actually mystery boxes he is selling. Either way - Harvey has said the offer was ok. On to the next offer. But the $150 was to spend in a sales thread that only has mystery boxes. Some of the mystery boxes have themes, some list an item or two, but in the end they are still mystery boxes. So can I now claim an item and say I will send you a box full of comics that will include X and Y, but it is valued at $125? I'm not trying to be picky, but to me a mystery box whether you list an item or two in the end is still a mystery box. I'd say what you are suggesting would be ok. If you say I'm including a X-Factor 6 and a ASM 361 and a bunch of other books valued at $150 then the person will be accepting the X-Factor 6 & ASM 361 and the mystery books are extra. But if you said I'm putting a X-Force 1 and 2 into a box and a mystery assortment of books valued at $150 then I could see a veto coming your way since the only know books are a X-Force 1 & 2 which would probably get vetoed. Most of this is just justification but I think it pretty obvious a person who offers a de-facto mystery box with a proven track record of offering great stuff is going to get a better reception than someone who people do not know. Is it 100% fair? Probably not but life is not 100% fair.

Nope the offer isnt rescinded or nope you wont let it slide It's not rescinded or I would have updated the first post. So I am confused, are Mystery Boxes okay now? I'm sure a true mystery box would be against the rules but giving someone $150 to spend in your sales thread is ok. Its definitely one of those grey areas but since ComicalGems has listed the keys in the boxes they are not actually mystery boxes he is selling. Either way - Harvey has said the offer was ok. On to the next offer.

If I'm allowed,I'll.take this. But I'm just off to bed,so stuff tomorrow afternoon. I just can't resist the pre hero stuff. If I'm allowed,that is. Jimmers I think you just took an offer less than a week ago so you will have to wait awhile to grab another one (other than the ones which sit for two days). The first page of the thread has the complete list of rules for the thread. It is a sweet offer!

He took option E which was pretty much one of ComicalGems $150 mystery boxes. Right now it could be a box containing a X-Factor 6 and ASM 361 or several others. Very nice offer.

Or just call it an ebay 5.5 Ouch - the kids gloves come off with that one. For people who did not look at the sellers name - it's the same book being offered up.

Wow. You would probably get anywhere from 3.0 - 4.0 in the Grading Thread. I'm in the 3.5 camp. Still a nice presenting book.

So when is the veto coming Always loved that book - still a little underrated in my book. 2nd sandman!

Geesh. Someone just take a flipping book already. People are making this way more difficult than it needs to be. Its the Giving Comics Tree not the donate a kidney tree.

I think it's a one of a kind custom sketch. I think he means option 3. (thumbs u The sketch is an Avengers book so I guess that makes more sense.

I think it's a one of a kind custom sketch.

I kind of liked Johnny Walker Black but I'm more of a whiskey and rum drinker.

Scotch scotch . . I love scotch.

Maybe he could de-slab it for you?

Nice books!!

Glad I could help sell it for CG.