PINWHEEL

Con sketch Rob was kind enough to do for me way back when.

Found some old school stickers in the dungeon.  Scud still rules. 
 

Found these while digging around the dungeon this morning.

Does anyone know if the stickers were originally attached to the book?  Or were they loose?  Every time I see a copy for sale with stickers they are loose.

On 4/23/2022 at 2:00 PM, Die Coinee, Die! said:

What year was it slabbed?

November of 2021.

I was under the impression that these books were too big for any current CGC slab but I came across one that sold on eBay and I pulled the certification and it's legit. Can't say it looks great squeezed into that slab.  And another question, if it's qualified for not having the stickers, what would CGC do with the if you see them in?  From the copy I have with stickers, they are loose, not attached to the book.

Here's a pic of the book in question:

Here's mine, cracked from a pgx case, came back from CGC as a 5.5.

Press would help, I say it's a really nice looking 6.5

9.0 for me

I'm not shocked at the landslide victory for 3.  If you can find a nice looking copy in your price range, grab it.

It's been about a year and a half but the book is finally on the way back after a long nightmare that thankfully turned out ok.  I'll update once it's in hand.

I'm an 8.0 on this one.

2.5 sounds about right to me.  A press would make it look nicer but I don't know that it pumps the grade up.

I could see this pulling a 3.5

My first ever submission to CGC was a group of 7 magazines for pressing and grading delivered in 11/2020, the first book (don't ask why it was separated out) arrived back about a 6 weeks ago, the other 6 are being graded now some 16 months after the original submission.  On the flip side I had a 25 book prescreen arrive to cgc on 12/20/21 and ship back to me on 1/5/22.  I figure it all balances out somehow.

3.5

9.2

I'm with the majority here, looks like a strong 7.5

Congrats to those who made the top 10.  I look forward to being much better next time.

Well I officially mess the bed and opened a spot in the top 10 for someone.  10 points in that round after only 8 in the first two rounds.

Wings Comics #1  1.8

Beware #10  4.5

Atom #1  6.0

Silver Surfer #1  7.0

Incredible Hulk #181  2.5

I'm a 9.0, but based off the current contest I don't know how to grade this book.

On 2/12/2022 at 10:04 PM, onlyweaknesskryptonite said:

Well mine wasn't the this time . 

 

Although I probably should still be concerned...

after emoji talk from last round I wouldn't be surprised if he was just toying with us now.  Or maybe I'm just telling myself that.

I'm in and a bit nervous.  Pressure of holding onto a top 10 spot may be getting to me or maybe it's the emoji that Mike added to the pm is making me question everything.

Really nice looking book.  6.5-7.0