All Star # 40 on ComicConnect- qualified grade?

[Antonio]

ComicConnect.com has a nice looking copy of All Star # 40 which lists as :

FN++ : 6.75

white pgs! interior coupon clipped (does not effect story).

 

It is a nice looking copy from the scan, but my understanding from the Grading Guide is that coupon cuts are only permitted in fair copies. I guess CGC would grade it with the Qualified sticker. Anyone have thoughts as how to properly grade and value this?

 

Thanks!

 

[nearmint]

Well, it looks nicer than the 7.0 Rockford copy on the same site. I agree that CGC would assign it the qualified label. As for actual grade, wouldn't it be nice if CGC would assign one of those, too, in a case like this?

 

Fair seems pretty harsh, considering it's an interior coupon that's been cut, and that it doesn't affect any story pages. I bet if this book was listed on eBay, it would sell in the area of $250.

[G.A.tor]

I guess a qualified grade would be appropriate....as to value, it is worth what you are willing to pay, but I suspect if it presents very nicely, pay g/vg price

rick

[nearmint]

Here's the book...

 

[G.A.tor]

looks nice...if you can live with the coupon cut, I stick to my g/vg offer (not sure what that is, no PG with me)

rick

[nearmint]

g/vg would be about $170.

[G.A.tor]

g/vg would be about $170.

go $175 for posterity sake

gator

[Antonio]

Thanks for the guidance everyone. GD/VG sounds reasonable to me 2.