Guess the CGC grade: Detective Eye #2, 1940 Centaur!

[Point Five]

Here's a slow pitch right down the plate for y'all...

 

Guess the grade! Qualified grade (centerfold missing), green label. Nice colors. Note the inch spine split ULC. Off-white pages, no other label notes.

 

 

 

 

 

[topofthetotem]

.5 incomplete?

[Point Five]

.5 incomplete?

 

 

Qualified grade.

 

Though honestly, I see your point because I have seen incomplete books graded .5. Dunno what the rules are exactly.

[joeypost]

Qualified 4.0

[topofthetotem]

If I have too I'd say it's a 4.5.

[gernblanston]

3.5 :shrug:

[divad]

Qualified 4.0

 

Textbook softball

[Sal]

VG-, although the colours look nice enough for it to go up to VG+

[rjpb]

Q 4.0 - but I could see CGC giving it a Q 3.5

[thedude]

Qualified 4.0

[143ksk]

If I have too I'd say it's a 4.5.

 

(thumbs u

[MutantKeys]

9.9 White Pages

[Blind Owl]

Qualified 4.0.

 

Looks pretty nice, too bad about the spine split & missing centerfold!!!

[divad]

Here's a slow pitch right down the plate for y'all...

 

Guess the grade! Qualified grade (centerfold missing), green label. Nice colors. Note the inch spine split ULC. Off-white pages, no other label notes.

 

 

I guess that the real question is, "Is the Qualified Label enough of a qualifier for something as significant as a missing wrap?"

 

I mean, it's not just like some little Marvel Value Stamp or coupon has been cut out of a non-story page . . . Presumedly, you're missing at a minimum, two pages of story art, and maybe even four

[Point Five]

Good question!

 

I'll post the label in the AM. Thanks for playing, folks...

[Timmay]

5.0

 

qualified, of course

[Mac Man]

Bottom left and right corners and the 1" spine split keep me from going any higher than a 4.0 (Q).

[Aces]

4.5 Q

[Aces]

Here's a slow pitch right down the plate for y'all...

 

Guess the grade! Qualified grade (centerfold missing), green label. Nice colors. Note the inch spine split ULC. Off-white pages, no other label notes.

 

 

I guess that the real question is, "Is the Qualified Label enough of a qualifier for something as significant as a missing wrap?"

 

I mean, it's not just like some little Marvel Value Stamp or coupon has been cut out of a non-story page . . . Presumedly, you're missing at a minimum, two pages of story art, and maybe even four

Your forgetting the infamous AF 15 that was missing everything inside but the Spider-Man story. What did it get? 6.0...6.5?

[JohnT]

4.0 for me. Big spine split, big crease, some of the paper missing in the lower left corner....can't go any higher I wouldn't think.