ASM #1

[Mac Man]

Hey all, just looking for your on this one. Below are the notes from the owner:

 

"The big flaw with the book is there is clear tape running along the inside of the cover (along the spine mostly) to add reinforcement. The book has no brittleness problems. The interior pages are in solid shape - no big flaws - page one has a few small symbols neatly penned on the bottom margin (see the back cover scan for what I mean). The whole book has a "worn/old" feel to it (meaning it is not rigid like a new book would feel). Structurally, it is not falling apart or anything like a FA copy would be. No pieces out, no coupons cut, no coloring, no major flaws other than the tape. There are horixontal tears on the cover along the binding (mostly on the back cover), but nothing too serious - to be expected in the GD range. Marvel chipping. And a heavy vertical reading crease/tear running along the spine (which the tape reinforces)."

 

Thoughts?

 

[CAP Freak]

2.0 IMO

[piper]

1.8 Good Luck with your negotiations!

[Dark Knight]

I said 1.8 too... Hope you get a good deal out of it if you are considering this copy.

[Mac Man]

Yeah, looked and sounded like a 1.8 to me as well- which is just fine by me. A LOT of it will depend on how much I can make in Warhammer models sales in the next couple days.

[gernblanston]

1.8 is the perfect grade here. Too nice for a 1.5 grade, and not quite up to a 2.0.

[Point Five]

A most respectable 1.8 (thumbs u

[JohnT]

1.8. Very, very worn, and that keeps it below a good. But no major defacing defects, which is a plus.

[trmoore54]

1.8 it is...I'd be happy to own this book!

[marvelcollector]

I went with 2.0...based on the description I want to go lower, but it just looks like a straight G.....

[snitzer]

Went w/ a 2.0 as this book as seen some love

[Mac Man]

...I'd be happy to own this book!

 

So would I. All depends on my fundraising ability.

[Comicdey]

I sold this as a fair, but CGC said 1.5

[Aces]

1.8

 

That's before checking and seeing it seems to be the choice grade.

[Mac Man]

Yeah, seems like it would be a solid GD- to a weak GD ( I also went with a 1.8) which was my initial thought.