PGM Giant Size X-men #1

[sckao]

 

Giant Size X-men #1

 

Notes: The corner is not bent but rounded over due to a slight overhang on the right hand side. Picked this up as part of a collection some months back.

 

 

[snitzer]

I'll dive in head first and go w/ a 9.0 give or take a few points. This is a tough one given the wear on each corner on the front cover, but the back looks great as does the rest of the front. Really nice book (thumbs u

 

This might be CGC worthy (I've seen some crazy things with books I've submitted) and definitely is vs. the #94 you have posted.

[Mac Man]

These should probably be slabbed before selling. You could probably make a solid run at a 9.0 and maybe a 9.2. URC crease with color break and the 4 corners could be a little sharper. That's it. Great looking book!

[cronoseptions-migration]

I agree. This is a very nice copy. 9.0

[piper]

Looks more like an 8.0

[gernblanston]

8.0

[nik]

VF+

[comic_lot]

8.5, due to blunted LLC and crease 3/4 way down spine in back. Nice looking book, bright white.

[Ze-man]

Yup, 8.0 safe grade, 8.5 on a good day.

 

 

[joeypost]

8.0/8.5

[Mac Man]

8.5, due to blunted LLC and crease 3/4 way down spine in back. Nice looking book, bright white.

 

Damn! Good eye- I missed that one. Looks like I finally overgraded on one I still think it could make a run for 9.0, but I think 9.2 is out. STILL probably worth slabbing though.

[comic_lot]

Definitely worth slabbing. CGC may be forgiving on minor defects for squarebounds.

[gernblanston]

Definitely worth slabbing. CGC may be forgiving on minor defects for squarebounds.

 

No question about it...CGC it. (thumbs u

[TFL-migration]

I'm in at 8.0 Presents very well from the scans.. But the overall wear keeps it out of a higher grade IMHO. Nice book to have slabbed. Sidenote: After what seemed a war with me and "The Hammer" I got a then CGG now PGX 9.9 White Pages copy. The seller was/is known for pulling some utter BS!! But the book I received is indeed the nicest copy I have ever seen. It's the nicest book I own to date.

[agro23]

I'm with the 8.0 / 8.5 crowd.

 

Still worth slabbing.

[djpinkpanther67]

8.0 definitely slabbable! :thumbsup:

[Calamerica]

8.0

[Icebreaka]

I'm going to be the lowest I guess at 7.5 to 7.0 range. That corner is definitely colour breaking based on the scan, I just can't see how it couldn't be in real life. Regardless I have this book with no corners out CGC'd at 7.5 and it looks pretty tight.

 

So ya I'll go 7.0 - 7.5, no way this book is 9.0 or 9.2 with that corner.