GA BEST ARTIST SURVIVOR SERIES POLL: FINAL ROUND

[rza808]

I think those panels shown hurt Eisner :shrug:

[The Black Hand ®]

Fair is fair, looks like Frazetta won. Congratulation to those who supported him.

[Ze-man]

What difference does it make? The same thing happens in presidential elections.

 

 

You radiate sunshine Doc.

 

Happy Halloween?

 

Ze-

 

 

[Theagenes]

What difference does it make? The same thing happens in presidential elections.

 

Maybe but THIS is important!

 

 

 

 

 

Well, in answer to Ze-Man's question, like most polls this one has a margin of error for sure, but I think in general the results are pretty representative. During this whole process of comparing these guys, all of whom are very talented, I think Frazetta and Eisner do stand out as being far ahead of their contemporaries. Just my

 

Jeff

[DrWatson]

What difference does it make? The same thing happens in presidential elections.

 

 

You radiate sunshine Doc.

 

Happy Halloween?

 

Ze-

 

I do what I can. Now, bask in my glory and like it!

 

[Comicdey]

Steve B....you need to pull some strings and get all your CGC workers to vote for Frazetta to go.....

[*paull*]

I am very surprised that people are looking at Frazetta fantasy paintings done in the 60s and 70s as reasons why he's a great artist, yet not acknowledging the rich visual vocabulary that Eisner developed in comics in the 40s and 50s.

 

Could you imagine what Eisner could have done if he worked in film? Maybe then he would have gotten proper recognition.

[TheWatcher]

Looks like Frank Frazetta is our winner! Congrats to Frank and thanks to all that voted and contributed to this poll. I think many of us have a greater appreciation for the work of these brilliant artists having been exposed to it

 

 

 

Angelo

[shiverbones]

close call. Wrong winner in my eyes, but both fantastic artists! Thanks Watcher for all the Work in getting it together!

[JohnT]

Thanks Watcher, it was a lot of fun, and I did indeed learn a lot about the GA. I'm sure I just scratched the surface, but it's made me very interested in learning more.

 

A worthy winner. I think it shows his unparalleled drawing skills that he could win without having a defining series or without really working on superhero titles.

[innocuous]

Great poll. Thanks Watcher.

 

I'd say the most fun was all the scans. Thanks to everyone who posted scans.

[CAP Freak]

Frazetta wins.

[toro]

Frazetta wins.

BOOOOOO for the winner!!!!!

 

But a (thumbs u for running the poll!!!

[rza808]

Frazetta wins.

[DrWatson]

Who's Frazetta?