guess the (non cgc) grade of my ASM 42 undercopy

[evilsly]

about to list this on fleabay as I have a much higher grade copy on the way.

 

my gut instinct on this book is it's way over graded (it's not graded by CGC, rather by those who may not be mentioned)

 

light effect on the back scan is the scanner not the book

 

off white pages

 

 

 

 

people seem to be pretty good at guessing cgc grades, it will be interesting to see how people do with this one.

 

 

[nik]

Looks like a PGX graded 7.5

[Comicdey]

4.5-5.0

[nik]

At best

 

Just wondering how they graded it.

plus the back scan really blurs out that water/moisture stain

[evilsly]

I'll reveal the pgx grade later tonight (my time)

 

 

[joeypost]

6.5

[djpinkpanther67]

Thay gave it a 7.0

[piper]

I agree with comicdey, looks like a 4.5.

[backtomarvel]

5.0 PGX

[Mr.Diggler]

5.0 sounds about right

[divad]

Is the chest hair in the case?

[The_Spirit]

I'll guess "they" gave it a 6.0 and I'd say it looks like a 4.5

[Count]

5.0

[evilsly]

in hand, it looks like a 4.5-5.0

 

 

in the hands of Daniel's team of crack graders (arf), or graders on crack (more likely)

 

 

the label sayeth

 

PGX 6.5

 

 

 

[JohnT]

in hand, it looks like a 4.5-5.0

 

 

in the hands of Daniel's team of crack graders (arf), or graders on crack (more likely)

 

 

the label sayeth

 

PGX 6.5

 

 

 

Amazing. I would say 4.5 also, with the stain, lots of spine creasing, and general loss of color.

[Aces]

My grade = 5.5

 

PGX (or whoever) = 7.0