PGM: Atom #1

[DCman]

Trying to figure out if it is worth getting this book slabbed. There is a NCB crease starting near the spine and extending towards the right over Atom's leg. What does everyone think?

 

 

[Goonchild-migration]

poss 5.5

[the_Greatest]

3.5

[burntboy]

this would be a great test book as it has numerous small defects. i'm not sure it'd get as high as a 5.5 because of that FC LRC creasing, the general funkiness of the BC spine (dirty/staining?), and the bottom edge which has four pretty damning defects.

 

i would opine that this could wind up being one of the prettiest 4.0-4.5 Atom #1's out there. the colors are still terrif............. (thumbs u

 

i'd probably still slab it, as it's a pre 1965 DC Key #1................. with a pretty cool looking cover, i might add..........

[JohnT]

I was going for 6.0 until I got to that lower right corner on the front.

 

I'll say 5.0.

[DCman]

this would be a great test book as it has numerous small defects. i'm not sure it'd get as high as a 5.5 because of that FC LRC creasing, the general funkiness of the BC spine (dirty/staining?), and the bottom edge which has four pretty damning defects.

 

i would opine that this could wind up being one of the prettiest 4.0-4.5 Atom #1's out there. the colors are still terrif............. (thumbs u

 

i'd probably still slab it, as it's a pre 1965 DC Key #1................. with a pretty cool looking cover, i might add..........

 

If I do decide to slab, I post it back on this thread.. Might be a few months though. Thanks for the comments Brunt.

[blue808]

5.0/5.5

[TFL-migration]

4.5 Just too much general wear overall to be any higher IMHO. Still a very nice book....

[gernblanston]

5.0

[TheAvenger80]

I'm sorry, I just don't see how this book gets anywhere near a 3.5. Solid Book IMO. 5.0-5.5