2008 GRADING CONTEST: ROUND 15

[greggy]

I dont want to Mess up Niks cool Guess the grade thread , but did anyone see what Flee did to Our Love #5 in the Silver Age Area in the Romance thread? Its good!!!!!

 

Thanks for pointing that out. First good laugh I had all day.

 

Completely at your expense.

Done months ago so old news. You coming up here or not?

 

Working on it.

I know where to go if you do.

[backtomarvel]

Man, it's a head-scratcher! White pages, a rigid spine. CGC's hard to figure.

[Mac Man]

Ok... I'm out. When I normally grade, I'm WAY under. When I overgrade, I'm WAY over. I'm just blind-guessing at this point. Good night all!

[Dick Pontoon]

I feel like the lower half of GACollectibles sig.

[Fan4Fan]

:censored:

[toro]

Ok... I'm out. When I normally grade, I'm WAY under. When I overgrade, I'm WAY over. I'm just blind-guessing at this point. Good night all!

 

I overgraded too! I'm a negative this time!!!

[joeypost]

In a PM I sent to Nik

 

"I predict I will be off one grade "

 

My guess was 8.0

[greggy]

white covers!

[Timmay]

I feel like the lower half of GACollectibles sig.

 

ouch

[mar-vell]

i graded it 9.0 and considered 8.5 but i have seen CGC 9.0's with rust marks on the BC and was worried about getting killed if the book did score a 9.2

[greggy]

In a PM I sent to Nik

 

"I predict I will be off one grade "

 

My guess was 8.0

[joeypost]

Man, it's a head-scratcher! White pages, a rigid spine. CGC's hard to figure.

 

Not really.

 

Impact dent

Transfer stains

A few spine tics

 

I said 8.0

[Timmay]

In a PM I sent to Nik

 

"I predict I will be off one grade "

 

My guess was 8.0

 

[joeypost]

In a PM I sent to Nik

 

"I predict I will be off one grade "

 

My guess was 8.0

 

Even when I am wrong, i am right.

[Warlord]

 

9.6 - 22

 

9.4 - 58

 

9.2 - 21

 

9.0 - 17

 

8.5 - 4

 

8.0 - 2

 

 

Based on the guesses, do you feel you were robbed! Resubmit??

 

[Timmay]

In a PM I sent to Nik

 

"I predict I will be off one grade "

 

My guess was 8.0

 

Even when I am wrong, i am right.

 

custom title

[greggy]

 

9.6 - 22

 

9.4 - 58

 

9.2 - 21

 

9.0 - 17

 

8.5 - 4

 

8.0 - 2

 

 

Based on the guesses, do you feel you were robbed! Resubmit??

The grade was accurate

[THE_BEYONDER]

[Warlord]

white covers!

[silverage12c]