PGM: FANTASTIC FOUR #2

[GAFLASH]

Thanks in advance.

Noticable defects are "5cent" written in marker near price. 1 & 1/2" X1"

water stain on top right. 3 tears at top near water stain. Staples attached firmly and relatively clean. Book complete with off-white to white pages. Back cover has bend on bottom edge. No spine splits. Very supple feel with good cover colors.

 

[GAFLASH]

Back cover of Fantastic Four #2

 

[marvelcollector]

2.5...water stain brings it down from VG IMO....

[Shadow]

I'd lean more towards a strong 2.0

[Aces]

2.5/3.0

 

3.0 if water stain doesn't or only barely affects the pages.

2.5 if it goes though most of the book.

[GAFLASH]

Water stain only affects cover page. Thanks for helping out guys.

[trmoore54]

I'd like to think CGC would go 3.0 on this book...in my mind no less that a 2.5. Not a bad copy at all considering the writing...

[djpinkpanther67]

GD

[silverage12c]

I see that it has been marked down to 5¢ . . . I think I'll

 

I would be inclined to say 3.0, as there aren't any sizable pieces out.

[Primetime]

nice GD+ 2.5

 

3.0 w/out water stain

[TFL-migration]

2.0

[burntboy]

I'll join in with the 3.0 crowd...............

[divad]

I'd like to think CGC would go 3.0 on this book...in my mind no less that a 2.5. Not a bad copy at all considering the writing...

 

Actually only you, SA12c, and Harry are close It is at a minimum a 3.0 and quite possibly a 3.5 based on the description and scans.

 

You other guys should crack out the grading guide, or look at some books that are actually graded 2.0

 

And Aces get over this BS water stain qualification - a freakin' water stain is a freakin' water stain - period.