PGM Tales of Suspense #40 2nd Iron Man !!!

[TheAvenger80]

Hey guys, I actually think it looks better in hand. Biggest things are a few small tears on front cover, somewhat minor marvel chipping, and on the back one 1" tear and one 1/2" tear near each other. Decent gloss actually, pretty nice spine, nice color. Just picked this up today and I'm feeling pretty about it Also, on the LFC that is NOT a tear going through that guys head, just a light scratch. What do you guys think?

 

 

[TheAvenger80]

Let me reiterate that the colors are definitely more dulled in the scan, and the gloss is not visible in the scan but it IS there! Just want to get informed opinions from you guys!!!

[NuffSaid57]

Nice book!! I will venture somewhere around 3.0/3.5 based on tears and extent of chipping.

[THE_BEYONDER]

I'd say 3.5

 

Book looks nicer than my 3.0 FF 1

[TheAvenger80]

For comparisons sake. I found this 4.0 on comic link:

 

[THE_BEYONDER]

Submit that bad boy. Wouldn't be surprised to see it come back 4.0 (thumbs u

[burntboy]

i'm thinking closer to 3.5. Maybe a 5.0 FC, but there's the two tears, the stress around the staples and kinda dirty BC. But 4.0 certainly not out of the question....................

[oakman29]

comparing the CGC scan to your raw scan it's not out of the question on getting a 4.0.I'd say 3.5/4.0

[marvelcollector]

3.5-4.0....leaning toward the higher grade, despite the tears......

[pinball]

I'll go with 4.0

 

[piper]

3.5

[TFL-migration]

3.5

[TheAvenger80]

Hey guys! Thanks for all the opinions! I would greatly appreciate any more! Do you guys think this is worth slabbing? To be honest, this is about my most valuable comic, and I don't see myself reading it much, if ever

[oakman29]

absolutely slab it,but you have to show us when it comes back.

[Aces]

3.5+

 

Might squeek out a 4.0 'cause CGC doesn't hammer chipping much...

 

[mysterymachine]

Yes it needs a slab! slab that baby! slab slab slab!

 

3.5 maybe 4.0 on good friday.

[burntboy]

Yup, slab fershure..........that's still a pretty valuable book in that grade. Mine's at CGC as we speak and is similar to yours (except for a smallish spine split and a nicer BC). I'm praying for at least a 4.0, but we'll see........... to you.

[Silver Surfer]

I'd say a 3.5. This is one of the first real SA books I have ever owned. Mine's about a 1.0 but I still love it.

[divad]

4.0 perhaps a 4.5, and yes, slab it.

[divad]

Yup, slab fershure..........that's still a pretty valuable book in that grade. Mine's at CGC as we speak and is similar to yours (except for a smallish spine split and a nicer BC). I'm praying for at least a 4.0, but we'll see........... to you.

 

Yours is at least a 5.0