GAB: Witching Hour #47

[sterlingcomics]

Grade a book...

[Justin Tnic Otyme]

Is that 10 spine ticks? And in a CGC case or PGX? 8.0-8.5

[Justin Tnic Otyme]

BTW Sterling the #83 H.O.S (2) have been submitted and I should know the grades by the end of next week.

[CAMERANIAC]

IMO, 8.0

[gernblanston]

7.5/8.0

[bronzilla]

Spines killing it 7.0 maybe 7.5

[NuffSaid57]

Corners look sharp enough despite the number of light spine ticks to merit 8.0/8.5.

[sterlingcomics]

Guys, if I could do a group hug right now, I'd do it...or at least a manly beer. I share the same sentiments.

 

This would've been a SWEET book to drag everyone down 2 points in the grading contest.

 

Here's what CGC thought:

Who was drunk at work the day this was graded? Apparently the entire team.

 

[gernblanston]

[Mr.Diggler]

Damn. I was gonna go 7.0! is right!!!!

[Justin Tnic Otyme]

Somebody better call the CGC police.

 

Because What the?

 

[CAMERANIAC]

That is very scary. They must give quite a bump for the black cover books.

[CAMERANIAC]

Somebody better call the CGC police.

 

Because What the?

 

Krey, what part of In. are you in, if you don't mind me asking?

[nochips]

7.5

[CJ]

Looks like CGC hired some new graders, blind graders at that.

 

Just shows buy the BOOK not the GRADE

[Weird]

Is that 10 spine ticks? And in a CGC case or PGX? 8.0-8.5

This year, I finally submitted a cool DC Bronze PGX 8.0 W I got off eBay like 4 years ago and it came back CGC 9.4 W. I thought it was undergraded, figured it for 9.0ish, but like the thread in general says, "I'm not a professional grader."

[JohnT]

CGC had to have made an error on the label.

[SEABISCUIT]

This is an April Fool joke, right?

[sterlingcomics]

This is an April Fool joke, right?

 

Nope. It's selling on eBay now...

[sterlingcomics]

CGC had to have made an error on the label.

Paul indicated that the notes of this book more or less matches the defects..."light stress marks on spine". Still, this is one for the hall of shame.