Is this a classic case of SCS?

[sterlingcomics]

To me, it seems as if the defect extends past the offending bump in the CGC holder. I don't think it is SCS.

 

I agree. I've seen that fugly book for a while...somebody please submit a couple of 9.6s/9.8s for krey and myself..we both need that one.

[sterlingcomics]

If anyone can come up with a better system to prevent SCS they will be happy to use it.

 

I know this sounds like I'm being a smart-, but freeing them from slabs is the only way I know.

[Justin Tnic Otyme]

I don't me to toot my own horn here and my P.S. #7 is not perfect by no means, but if that is a 9.4 what should this grade out as?

[sterlingcomics]

9.4

 

Yours is acurately graded. This other is...well...a tragedy.

[CAMERANIAC]

I don't me to toot my own horn here and my P.S. #7 is not perfect by no means, but if that is a 9.4 what should this grade out as?

I wouldn't mind seeing a close-up pic of the top edge.