PGM Planet 57

[JvR11]

Here is another Planet I'm interested in opinions on. I was told it was VF/NM. What do you all think? Any and all opinions appreciated! I'm thinking about filling out the special offer coupon I think 1.69 is a great deal. In seriousness, if you think it's a VF what prevents it from being an NM?

 

 

 

 

 

[Aces]

8.0 Spine ticks/stress

[Mutie Fan]

8.0 Spine ticks/stress

 

I agree. Front is better than the back but what a great book!

[piper]

8.0 Spine ticks/stress

 

(thumbs u

[TFL-migration]

9.0 I'd take 8.0's from this era all day long if they looked this nice.

[JvR11]

Do you think pressing would get this out and bring the grade up?

[nik]

I think it can be pressed to a 9.0 maybe even a 9.2 considering its a GA book

[CAP Freak]

YES. Pressing can seriously help this book into NM status.

[JohnT]

From what I can see, I'd be comfortable with 9.0.

[rjpb]

Scan is a bit small - but 8.5- 9.0 seems about right - rear spine stress, stacking bend, slight dust shadow on lower BC, slight rounding on URC (is there a small ncb crease there as well?) - conspire to keep it out of NM range. Still a beautiful copy

[JvR11]

Thank you all, I appreciate the feedback...I'm betting based on averages it's about an 8.5 but if pressed could go to 9.0. I plan on keeping it so I'll probably forgo the pressing. I wish all my GA comics were this nice!

[sakaridis]

No way this book is only an 8.0!

 

It looks too good even for an 8.5. Personally, I'd say it's probably a 9.0, so yeah, VF/NM is about right. (thumbs u

 

Super cool book, by the way.

[Silver Surfer]

Scans a bit small but is that a stain on the top edge of the book? Those creases on the back look pretty noticable and is there a dust shadow on the top left edge of the spine or is that a spine roll (thinking its a dust shadow?). Also, is there a bit of a staple pull at the bottom? 7.5 to 8.0.

[JvR11]

I've attached bigger scans so more can be seen. There is no spine roll. I'm not sure about how to judge staple pull. It's attached really well together. When do you start to judge staple pull? I think it's just generally where the staple is located.

 

 

 

[blue808]

8.5

 

[TheAvenger80]

Sweet book. I think this is at least an 8.5

[TFL-migration]

9.0