Mis-wraps this bad should be disqualified from 9.8 status

[nmtg9]

there are well centered copies on ebay with the 9 on

[topofthetotem]

but are they graded 9.8 by cgc?

[MrBedrock]

The seller probably does, that is why he is dumping that 9.8

Can't have a well centered copy of that book without the 9 being cut off, Greek

So a well centered copy would get a .8 from CGC?

Correct, tall lanky geeky Texan

[greggy]

but are they graded 9.8 by cgc?

Plus, having the 9 doesn't mean that it's well centered. It just means that it's miswrapped to the back.

[seanfingh]

but are they graded 9.8 by cgc?

Plus, having the 9 doesn't mean that it's well centered. It just means that it's miswrapped to the back.

 

Dorkus Maximus.

[greggy]

but are they graded 9.8 by cgc?

Plus, having the 9 doesn't mean that it's well centered. It just means that it's miswrapped to the back.

 

Dorkus Maximus.

You know I'm right.

[seanfingh]

but are they graded 9.8 by cgc?

Plus, having the 9 doesn't mean that it's well centered. It just means that it's miswrapped to the back.

 

Dorkus Maximus.

You know I'm right.

 

Unfortunately for you, being right does not, in the least, lessen dorkiness.

[greggy]

but are they graded 9.8 by cgc?

Plus, having the 9 doesn't mean that it's well centered. It just means that it's miswrapped to the back.

 

Dorkus Maximus.

You know I'm right.

 

Unfortunately for you, being right does not, in the least, lessen dorkiness.

to dorkiness and for being right.

[topofthetotem]

You sir are correct!

[greggy]

You sir are correct!

[seanfingh]

but are they graded 9.8 by cgc?

Plus, having the 9 doesn't mean that it's well centered. It just means that it's miswrapped to the back.

 

Dorkus Maximus.

You know I'm right.

 

Unfortunately for you, being right does not, in the least, lessen dorkiness.

to dorkiness and for being right.

 

[He11blazer]

Just got this in the post today. Picked up as an extra from a comiclink auction. When I'm paying shipping for 1 to 3 books, it feels like a waste to only get 1 you see. Came in well under GPA presumably because of the funky angle. Will be shamelessly flipped.

 

 

 

[joe_collector]

Why? it is manufactured like that.

 

So if a book was torn apart by the pressing machine, then sold, it too deserves a 9.8 if structurally consistent with its "off the presses" condition?

 

Comics are the only graded collectible I know where production defects are NOT taken into consideration.

[DrWatson]

Why? it is manufactured like that.

 

So if a book was torn apart by the pressing machine, then sold, it too deserves a 9.8 if structurally consistent with its "off the presses" condition?

 

Comics are the only graded collectible I know where production defects are NOT taken into consideration.

Of course not. Don't be silly. If it's torn in half, then you would have two 9.8s. (thumbs u

[joe_collector]

Of course not. Don't be silly. If it's torn in half, then you would have two 9.8s. (thumbs u

 

[dekeuk]

Why? it is manufactured like that.

 

It was not damaged by handling/storing/reading and completely deserving of the 9.8.

 

 

Tell that to a sports card collector. I don't collect them but I know the Gretzky rookie is notorious for not being centered correctly.

 

 

 

 

[cd4ever]

You sir are correct!

I completely disagree with you.

[topofthetotem]

yes I could care less what sport card collectors think about what a 9.8 comic should look like.

And I may add a comic is not a single sheet of cardboard but multiple wraps placed together much more difficult to manufacture.

 

An off center cover is no comparison to a destroyed book being sent out to the newstands. Come on Vince, give me a break.