2008/09 Grading Contest: Round 1

[comicdonna]

Tough book! I should have spent more time in the grading forum (well, at least some time).

 

When I clicked on this category, there were 17,000+ unread posts in here! Guess I don't spare many grades...

[Old Fashion PB and J]

I'm sensing alot of negatives in this round

 

Good thing there are no minus 2 points awarded

 

Everyone's paranoid about the (so-called?) "tough new CGC grading standards"...

 

Every book I ever submitted came back 9.8

 

All 5 of them

[silverage12c]

 

Every book I ever submitted came back 9.8

 

All 5 of them

Four X-Force #1s and a Super-Pro?

 

J/K, Pat --- Actually, I am curious. Did you really submit 5 and get 5 9.8s back? Which books?

[JohnT]

And no discussing books that are on the clock, or face public humiliation like you've never seen...

[Twistty1]

I'm sensing alot of negatives in this round

 

Good thing there are no minus 2 points awarded

 

Everyone's paranoid about the (so-called?) "tough new CGC grading standards"...

 

Every book I ever submitted came back 9.8

 

All 5 of them

 

Thats 5 for 5...good percentage..wanna submit one or two for me?

[Count]

[TSwift25]

[piper]

[greggy]

9.9

[Aces]

Grade sent.

 

Who's gonna do the chart?

[comicgrinder]

[Old Fashion PB and J]

 

Every book I ever submitted came back 9.8

 

All 5 of them

Four X-Force #1s and a Super-Pro?

 

J/K, Pat --- Actually, I am curious. Did you really submit 5 and get 5 9.8s back? Which books?

 

Ultimate Fantastic Four 31 Suydam variant that I had him sign.

 

Wanted #1 I bought from a dealer in philly to get signed by JG Jones.

 

All-Star Batman and Robin 10 (I sold alot of these that were 9.8's)

 

Walking Dead #1 (the book was my friends, I checked it out for him) Just sold on Ebay as a SS for $400.00

 

Uncanny X-Men 132 Hellfire club. Pulled it off my wall display in Philly, was offered for sale before submitting at straight NM- OSPG price. Sold for $375.00

[Old Fashion PB and J]

Grade sent.

 

Who's gonna do the chart?

 

You brought it up.

[Transplant]

Nik:

 

Will there be a break around thanksgiving?

[cloudofwit]

Nik:

 

Will there be a break around thanksgiving?

 

No way, turkey.

[gernblanston]

[nik]

Yes,

 

Round 2 will start Tuesday night and extend to Friday night.

 

We have 156 players for this contest

 

all but 62 have submitted grades already :o

[djpinkpanther67]

I totally forgot about it :doh: ...grade sent!

[trmoore54]

Yes,

 

Round 2 will start Tuesday night and extend to Friday night.

 

We have 156 players for this contest

 

all but 62 have submitted grades already :o

 

Putting a hundred or so players in the hole in Round 1 due to non-submittal of their grade...PRICELESS!

[General Zod]

Yes,

 

Round 2 will start Tuesday night and extend to Friday night.

 

We have 156 players for this contest

 

all but 62 have submitted grades already :o

 

Putting a hundred or so players in the hole in Round 1 due to non-submittal of their grade...PRICELESS!

 

62 = 'a hundred or so'? Heh heh...