ASM #4 AND FF #6

[hbo_boxingfan]

o.k. I have a couple books that I wanna get regraded by cgc. I wanna get some opinions on what you might think they will come back as. If you think they'll grade close to what they are now, I think it will be worth the effort.

 

First up, an ASM #4 graded by the "other" guys as a 5.0. I'm thinking of getting the book pressed due to the light crease running down the entire right side of the book. on the right side of the crease the paper almost looks like there was maybe moisture damage but I can't tell for sure.

 

 

 

 

Second book, a FF #6 is in the old ccgroup world holder and was graded a 6.5. Any marks you see running throught the title are on the holder.Thanks guys for your feedback. (thumbs u

 

 

 

[ROBTOTHEC]

5.5 and 6.0 ??

[Dick Pontoon]

The ASM is not worth getting pressed. With staining on the front and back from the water damage, rusty staples with migration and tear UFRC, I doubt if it would come back higher than a 4.0.

[hbo_boxingfan]

The ASM is not worth getting pressed. With staining on the front and back from the water damage, rusty staples with migration and tear UFRC, I doubt if it would come back higher than a 4.0.

 

thanks. I felt the ASM was overgraded but wasn't exactly sure how much so. I thought the FF maybe had a shot at a 6.0 and would be very happy if it came back at that. I leaning more towards just sending in the FF as i'm more confident it will get a decent grade. the ASM is probably just better left the way it is I guess.

[mysterymachine]

The ASM is not worth getting pressed. With staining on the front and back from the water damage, rusty staples with migration and tear UFRC, I doubt if it would come back higher than a 4.0.

 

I agree the first book will definitly drop. 4.0 seems about right.

The second book looks to be 6.0/6.5. I don't expect it will grade higher then that.

[MagnetoWasRight]

Yeah, I'd go 4.0/4.5 and 6.5

[Primetime]

The ASM is not worth getting pressed. With staining on the front and back from the water damage, rusty staples with migration and tear UFRC, I doubt if it would come back higher than a 4.0.

 

CGC is very tough on water damage and staining--I've seen them drop a grade 1.0-2.0 points on an otherwise nice book, structurally

 

Nice books though Two of my favorites from the SA (thumbs u

[marvelcollector]

4.0/4.5 and 6.0/6.5.....

[Aces]

The ASM is not worth getting pressed. With staining on the front and back from the water damage, rusty staples with migration and tear UFRC, I doubt if it would come back higher than a 4.0.

Both books look over-graded.

 

ASM 4 = 4.0

FF 6 = 5.0

[hbo_boxingfan]

thanks guys. Not surprised. there the only two pgx books I own and I knew when I bought them I was taking a chance. of course, I still need to worry about a purple label.

[Bunky Brian]

The ASM is not worth getting pressed. With staining on the front and back from the water damage, rusty staples with migration and tear UFRC, I doubt if it would come back higher than a 4.0.

 

CGC is very tough on water damage and staining--I've seen them drop a grade 1.0-2.0 points on an otherwise nice book, structurally

 

Nice books though Two of my favorites from the SA (thumbs u

 

(thumbs u

[trmoore54]

4.0/4.5 and 6.0/6.5.....

 

Agreed!

 

A couple of nice books and two of my favorites as well!

[JohnT]

It looks like they slabbed the FF 6 with the back corner turned over.

 

I agree with the consensus. The Spidey is a max of 4.0 with the water damage and rust, but the FF looks nice and could get a 6.0. And a CGC 6.0 would be worth a lot more than a PGX 6.5...

 

Great issues, wish I owned both of them!