Are we really calling this Skywald Nightmare #1 from 1970 a VF !?!?

[bounty_coder]

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=310150308279&ssPageName=ADME:B:SS:US:1123

 

Looks more like a FN 6.0 TOPS ?!?!

[ROBTOTHEC]

With the wear and the small tears I would say 5.5/5.0!

All the corners are blunted, abrasion along the spine, tear on

the bottom. UNBELEIVABLE the grading on Ebay sometimes!

 

[divad]

More like a VG . . .

 

Seller info

mycomicshop ( 47825 [Feedback score is 25,000 to 49,999] ) Member is a PowerSeller

99.6% Positive feedback

Read feedback profile

 

No thanks

[The Silver-Age]

I'd say a 5.0-5.5

[Limited66]

I think 5.5/6.0 is probably more like it, but I've heard less than positive things about this outfit. Although I bought a coupla Caps from them that were as described.

[burntboy]

With the wear and the small tears I would say 5.5/5.0!

All the corners are blunted, abrasion along the spine, tear on

the bottom. UNBELEIVABLE the grading on Ebay sometimes!

 

nice concise summary... (thumbs u

 

That tear on the bottom with it's ensuing additional crease is a real grade killer. and with all four corners blunted and creased, i'd think somewhere in the 5.0 range is about right.

 

but, it's a big scan and folks can make an informed decision as to what they think it's worth.....(and it is about an E-bay VF... )