PGM: FF #7

[lzaidel-migration]

Hello esteemed graders,

 

Would you please offer your opinions on the grade of this book?

 

Thank you in advance.

 

Liam

 

 

 

 

[oakman29]

6.5 (thumbs u

[zuckuss2003]

Looks like a 5.5/6.0

[lzaidel-migration]

Thanks so far...How about the smudge on the "F" in "Fantastic"? Just got this off E-bay and I'd like to send it in to CGC to be graded, but wanted to get second opinions first.

[TFL-migration]

5.5 IMHO. Nice book.

[The Silver-Age]

5.0-5.5

[jimjum12]

6.0.....GOD BLESS....

 

-jimbo(a friend of jesus) (thumbs u

[mrlatko]

I'm leaning towards 4.5/5.0. That spine looks pretty rough to me, and the stain isn't helping things.

[Short Stack]

5.0

[The Silver-Age]

I am looking closer at the back cover. Has the top edge been trimmed? Very miscut. At first I thought maybe it's just a little warping, but if you look at the reader edge side, it definately drops off a lot.......

[The Silver-Age]

I'm leaning towards 4.5/5.0. That spine looks pretty rough to me, and the stain isn't helping things.

 

What stain?

[comicfanatic20-migration]

5.0

[The Silver-Age]

Seriously. Check the top edge for trimming.....

[Boozad]

5.0. And it does look like Stevie Wonder did a trim job on it

[lzaidel-migration]

Yes, good eyes...Why that little #$@%...Ok, I should probably assume he didn't know. It really does look like a pretty botched trimming, like someone with Parkinson's tremor took some scissors to it. Can anyone think of something else that could account for this phenomenon?

 

[zuckuss2003]

I thought the BC looks odd also, but figured it was a bad scan or something, why would someone trim a book with the spine looking that rough?

[Earl Davis]

5.5

[lzaidel-migration]

So what would the grade be after the trimming if in fact it was trimmed?

[crazyhips]

4.0. I think smudges in the indica get hammered pretty hard.

[The Silver-Age]

I would still say in the 5.0 range. But it would obviously be a Purple.