Avengers 59 Grade revealed!!!

[colugo]

I got this one back today and I wanted to see what you guys say before I reveal the grade. All corners and edges are sharp. flat and glossy cover. WP according to owl guide.

 

 

BTLC is there, it's just curved a bit, but no crease.

 

[blue808]

9.6

[erehwon]

9.6?

[TFL-migration]

9.4 IMHO

[rednalsram]

I'm not familiar with this comic, is there a bit of a rub by the front top staple, or is that

how the artwork looks?

 

If no rub, then I say 9.8.

[Short Stack]

9.6

[oakman29]

9.6

(thumbs u

[VK]

9.4/9.6

[The Silver-Age]

9.6-9.8

 

Did you have this on here for us to see before you subbed it?

[WEBHEAD]

9.4-9.6

 

?

 

 

 

 

WEBHEAD

[etanick]

wow, another beauty

 

9.6

[colugo]

Ok, I'm getting close to revealing the final results any last guess's on the grade. If I get at least four more grades I promise I'll post a number one from one of my titles I own.

[colugo]

The Silver-Age

 

Did you have this on here for us to see before you subbed it?

 

No, I just went ahead and sent this in at the last minute and forgot to post it on this thread.

[Inhuman Fiend]

9.6....coulda been a 9.8 if pressed

[cheetah]

Gotta be a 9.8. Way too pretty to be a 9.6.

[colugo]

I thought pressed was something collectors frown upon, or am I wrong? and besides this book is really much more nicer when viewed in person, you have to take my word for it, the book looks brand new. I know your thinking because a couple of the corners are slightly curved but in my opinion I don't think that should be a factor in the grade as long as there is no crease Sending comics in the mail always makes me wonder if they'll incur damage through transit no matter how well you pack them, so sending it to get pressed then sending to CGC means more transit time and to me more opportunity for damage, too risky for this book at least. I'm thinking of inventing a restore gun were you just point it at the comic and pull the trigger and "Presto!" instant restoro. What do you think? I think it'll sell like hot cakes after a sunday service.

 

Thanks for your input though.

[The Silver-Age]

If they graded this a 9.4 I'm gonna puke.

[supapimp]

9.6

[cheetah]

I hate it when I mislabel files.

[colugo]

Here's my 9.4 for comparison.

 

 

Hey, I got that one too. Thats a nice looking copy, nice grade.