Bet settler 2 - Dr Strange 1

[JohnBull]

As much to test my awful scanning and attaching skills as anything. Any guesses ?

 

[burntboy]

unfortunately, most of the right edge and some of the bottom got cropped-out.

despite that, if the missing edges look as nice as the visible portions i'd think this is also in the 9.4 area..............

[JohnBull]

Bugger. Don't know why that happened, but I'll rescan later and try again. Told you I was incompetent.

[JohnBull]

OK, I'm learning. Proper picture showing, now for Defenders 10. Thanks.

[FFB]

Based on front cover and what wear I can see, 9.4.

[Foolkiller]

I agree... 9.4 looks about the ballpark.

[sterlingcomics]

slight chance 9.2 most likely 9.4

[FFB]

Two lawyers just agreed on something. Someone call the Guiness Book.

 

I agree... 9.4 looks about the ballpark.

[PovertyRow]

Two lawyers just agreed on something. Someone call the Guiness Book.

 

I agree... 9.4 looks about the ballpark.

 

Beftore you call Guiness you have to determine of they are both defense lawyers, prosecutors, or one of each. If one of each call Guiness IMMEDIATELY!!!!!!!!!

[supapimp]

9.4 maybe a 9.6

[FFB]

I was going to say "No way is that LRC sharp enough for a 9.6," but then I remembered the Daredevil #200 9.8 that I posted here earlier.

 

9.4 maybe a 9.6

[Pickey_Grader-migration]

Sorry 9.2

 

[Rocketeer]

9.4

[uclapeterg]

9.4/9.6

[rjpb]

What is that white mark underneath the price box?

[nik]

9.2 maybe 9.4

[sfilosa]

I really see nothing on the scan (which is a bit blurry) that would make me downgrade the book at all. It's probably not a 10.0 but it could be in the 9.4-9.8 range (no way to tell accept in person).

 

Does anyone see a stress line?

Does anyone see a corner crease?

 

If the answer is no, you have say at least a 9.4-9.6.

 

I can't stand when people downgrade scans based on the perception that there MUST be DEFECTS, even though not present in the scan.

 

That's like a jury convicting someone on the theory, that there must be more evidence pointing to someones guilt that wasn't presented during the trial.

 

INNOCENT until PROVEN GUILTY applies to comic books also.