PGM: X-men #1

[loboagain]

Thoughts please. Thanks.

 

 

[oakman29]

A little spine roll,but over all looks very nice. 4.5 (thumbs u

[zuckuss2003]

I was thinking 4.0 originally but I think it could hit a 4.5 like oakman says.

[oakman29]

I was thinking 4.0 originally but I think it could hit a 4.5 like oakman says.

Yeah I could see either grade,but thought it had a nice eye appeal so I gave it the higher grade.

[tortoise]

very solid VG imo, very nice (thumbs u

[etanick]

hmmm...unless I am missing something here, I see a much nicer book than 4.0/4.5

 

I think you have a shot at something much higher...are you submitting the book? if so let us the result later because the book looks like a 6.0 to me if not higher.

[John R]

4.5/5.0

[blue808]

5.5

[ARK]

5.0

[Boozad]

Solid 5.0, outside 5.5.

[TSwift25]

5.0

[Lethal_Collector]

I'm gonna agree with the consensus on this one. When I compare it to my 4.5, it's just slightly better all around 5.0/maybe 5.5

 

Jerome

[faster friends]

5.0

[TFL-migration]

5.0 IMHO. Nice book!

[Hero Restoration]

5.0 maybe 5.5 Really clean book and would grade much higher if it wasn't for the front bottom right spider creases.

 

4.0? Not if you are comparing it to this.

 

 

 

[thehumantorch]

Looks like a 5.0. How is the top staple as the book looks kinda funky in that area from the front scan?

[loboagain]

Looks like a 5.0. How is the top staple as the book looks kinda funky in that area from the front scan?

 

Front staple is fine and is on the spine of the book. The second staple is off center. Oh well.

 

Book is going to CGC so I will post once I get it back.

 

I think the book has a shot at 5.5.

[oakman29]

Looks like a 5.0. How is the top staple as the book looks kinda funky in that area from the front scan?

 

Front staple is fine and is on the spine of the book. The second staple is off center. Oh well.

 

Book is going to CGC so I will post once I get it back.

 

I think the book has a shot at 5.5.

[faster friends]

5.0 maybe 5.5 Really clean book and would grade much higher if it wasn't for the front bottom right spider creases.

 

4.0? Not if you are comparing it to this.

 

 

 

 

What were the graders smoking when the evaluated this book?

[apollobuzz]

I'm going with the 5.0 crowd. (thumbs u