all winners 9 "the photos are here"

[Junkdrawer]

CGC Registry shows 8.5 as highest, will this book beat that?

 

 

 

 

 

[Junkdrawer]

i figured it out, pissed off a few boardies, in the process

[143ksk]

 

If you can press out that crease down the middle, then yes, it should be better than an 8.5

[mystrymachine]

you will also need to post a pic of the back cover. Looks like a very nice book!

[Junkdrawer]

back photo is here!

[Hero Restoration]

Can it really get a 9.0 with the paper missing at the top of the spine and along the top edge near the spine?

[etanick]

I think 8.5 is doable here...gorgeous copy and if you ever want to let it go.

 

[marvelcollector]

7.5 with that piece missing and the dust shadow...

[faster friends]

I think you should have the BC dry cleaned and have the book pressed. May have a shot then...

[Junkdrawer]

once it comes back, it will be up for sale, ebay, possibly clink's nov. focused, i got time and i'm into it for serious short money.

[etanick]

http://www.cgccomics.com/census/grades_standard.asp?title=All%20Winners%20Comics&publisher=Timely%20Comics&issue=9&year=1943&issuedate=Summer%201943

 

looks like there is a 9.0 already...good luck with the submission to CGC. I am sure you won't have any problems on Ebay or CL selling that book.

[143ksk]

Can it really get a 9.0 with the paper missing at the top of the spine and along the top edge near the spine?

 

yes

[djpinkpanther67]

Can it really get a 9.0 with the paper missing at the top of the spine and along the top edge near the spine?

 

yes

+1..... GA Bump

[nearmint]

Depends on whether they consider it a bindery chip. And 143ksk is right about that light center crease. If you don't press it out, CGC will nail the book for it. Pressing will also help that spine lay flat. Right now it has a slight roll.

[Hibou]

I'd put it at a 8.5 straight as is...

 

BEAUTIFUL copy!!!!

 

 

[ChasingKingKirby]

Can it really get a 9.0 with the paper missing at the top of the spine and along the top edge near the spine?

 

Looks production related on the spine, so yes, it can make 9.0 with bindery tears. I think the soiled back-cover may be the bigger problem, but dry-cleaning may also solve that problem. That's the prettiest raw I've seen.

[TFL-migration]

8.0 IMHO

[VintageComics]

Can it really get a 9.0 with the paper missing at the top of the spine and along the top edge near the spine?

 

Looks production related on the spine, so yes, it can make 9.0 with bindery tears. I think the soiled back-cover may be the bigger problem, but dry-cleaning may also solve that problem. That's the prettiest raw I've seen.

 

I don't think that wear at the top is production related but it is a pretty book. Tough to grade without a large scan. Are there any creases at the bottom left edge back cover or is that just dirt?

[Junkdrawer]

that issue on the bottom back corner was actually a fold in the last page and dirt did accumulate on the cober in that area appearing like a crease. i carefully unfolded the page and cleaned the dirt off. sent it out yesterday and hope to get it into clinks nov focused, cutting it close though, we'll see.

[Primetime]

Structurally looks like 8.5/9.0 with the bindary chip. Nice book. What's the history on it ownership wise?