Dr. TDcomicscards or "How I learned to Start Worrying and Hate CGG"

[Rip]

I hope to contact both CGG and tdcomicscards and see what they have to say.

But here it is.......

[Rip]

Before...

[Darthdiesel]

[JiveTurkeyMoFo]

Look at the bright side, you got the gift grade from CGC...

 

J/K...bummer deal dude...

[Darthdiesel]

careful Rip, the CGG faithful will soon be accusing you of color touching the 9.2 book just because you want to ruin CGG. Then they'll harp on the fact that cgc gave it a 9.6 calling them overrgraders, meanwhile oblivious still to the fact that CGG undergrades on purpose...

[greggy]

[blowout]

You don't think that Rip color touched the book himself to get the 9.6?

[sckao]

 

So if you got Neal Adams to sign over the color touch with a felt pen at a convention with a CGC rep present, would that still get a PLOD or would you then have a 9.6 signature series Batman #238?

 

(nice book otherwise...one of the books I'm collecting from my childhood.)

[Rip]

I thought 9.6 was generous, I could see 9.4, but

Its quite a risk to buy CGG

[fazman]

So if you got Neal Adams to sign over the color touch with a felt pen at a convention with a CGC rep present, would that still get a PLOD or would you then have a 9.6 signature series Batman #238?

 

(nice book otherwise...one of the books I'm collecting from my childhood.)

[Rip]

[Darthdiesel]

knowing Rip, i know he wouldn't even think of it, bur I'd rather sound like an insufficiently_thoughtful_person and say it first than actually have someone who believes that he would and come out and insult him by accusing him of doing so...

 

and Rip - maybe the CT give it an apparent 9.6 look

[fantastic_four]

I'm finding it a little hard to believe they missed amateur CT. That should mean there's BLEEDTHROUGH!!

 

Feel like busting open the case and looking for where the CT is? I definitely would if I were you.

[FFB]

Why don't you turn TDComix in to ebay? And tell CGG too. Maybe CGG will stop accepting submissions from TDComix? I mean, they'll take a 50% immediate hit to their revenues , but you should at least give them the opportunity to do the right thing.

[fantastic_four]

Maybe CGG will stop accepting submissions from TDComix?

 

If memory serves, RS said in another thread they already took this stand.

[Kevin Boyd]

So if you got Neal Adams to sign over the color touch with a felt pen at a convention with a CGC rep present, would that still get a PLOD or would you then have a 9.6 signature series Batman #238?

 

Nope... resto trumps signatures, even if they are signed in front of a CGC rep they will get a purple label.

 

K

[Rip]

Daniel was very quick to answer his e-mails.

We are discussing the problem right now.......

[BachelorOfComix]

I am SHOCKED!

[FFB]

Post them in real time? As a public service announcement, you know.

 

Daniel was very quick to answer his e-mails.

We are discussing the problem right now.......

[Rip]

In short so far, wanted to know what was missed, wanted to see the scans I offered

It will be interesting to get grading notes from both CGG and CGC on this one.