PGM Fantastic Four 12

[68 Birdman-migration]

As you can see in the pics there is quite a bit of tanning (dust shadow) bordering the BC and FC. Other than that also note the green stain on top of the BC and chips on left edge of BC.

 

[Hibou]

4.5

[KPvD2011]

4.0 IMHO

[ARK]

WTTB. Scans are better than photos. I would go 4.5. (thumbs u

[68 Birdman-migration]

Thanks for the welcome and the feedback. I will scan the next ones I post. I made my first purchase ever of vintage comic books after coming across a lot of about 40 low number Silver Age.

 

This forum has been a great way for me to learn about comic grading. To test my skills I look at the pics in this forum, make my grade, and then look at the replies to see how close I come to the consensus. I have made it through about 5 or 6 pages of posts thus far and am at least in the ballpark now with my assessments. BTW, I self-graded this one at four.

[Sandflea]

4.0

[thehumantorch]

4.5 Welcome to the boards birdman. I'm not sure why you purchased the

books, for resale or to keep, but either way FF12 is a great start. Early FF,

first crossover and early appearance of the Hulk. A great little read and easy

to sell for good money.

[68 Birdman-migration]

4.5 Welcome to the boards birdman. I'm not sure why you purchased the

books, for resale or to keep, but either way FF12 is a great start. Early FF,

first crossover and early appearance of the Hulk. A great little read and easy

to sell for good money.

 

Thanks Torch ... I can't really call myself a collector yet since this is my first purchase, but I can see where this could become an addiction!

[Calamerica]

4.0

[MARVEL MANIAC-migration]

My favorite MARVEL cover of all time!

[Zushi-migration]

Ditto, one of my ALL-TIME favorite covers!

I'm far from very good at grading but I did have a comic that looked similar that I believe was a 4.5.

[Old Fashion PB and J]

VG 4.0

[68 Birdman-migration]

Thought y'all would be interested ... I CGCd this and it was graded as a 4.0 so you all were spot on!